Experts beg the Supreme Court to overturn Oracle/Google ruling

The Supreme Court has received an outpouring of amicus briefs from the tech industry and law professors imploring the highest court in the land to hear Oracle’s long-running case against Google — and rule in favor of Google.

Those asking the high court to take the case include Mozilla, Microsoft, the Python Software Foundation, Red Hat, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and a list of 65 IP scholars, among others.

Read: Warren Buffett says he ditched his stake in Oracle because of his experience getting burned by IBM

This involves the endless suit over the use of Java application programming interfaces (APIs) in Google’s Android operating system. APIs allow software programs to talk to each other and share data or information. Nine years ago, Oracle sued Google, claiming it uses APIs taken from Java in violation of copyright law. Java is owned by Oracle.

Oracle first lost the case, but then won on appeal, and the Supreme Court declined to hear the case. Instead, the high court sent the case back to lower courts to hear Google’s second argument, which is that Java’s APIs fell under the Fair Use doctrine of copyright law. Again, Oracle lost the first case, and then again won on appeal.

And now Google has asked the Supreme Court to take up what would likely be the final appeal on the case.

So the industry has piled in asking the Supreme Court “to clean up the Oracle v. Google mess,” as the EFF puts it.

The EFF and others who filed briefs believe the computer industry is harmed when APIs cannot be freely copied, making it easier for programmers to get software to work together. Google’s supporters in this case argue that if APIs must be licensed, it will dramatically increase costs for programmers, and possibly lead to an uptick in nuisance lawsuits. Some of these briefs are making other arguments for overturning the appeals ruling, as well.

Oracle believes these arguments are without merit. It still hopes to keep its win and force Google to pay it billions in damages for the use of Java.

“Despite Google’s and its amici’s overheated rhetoric predicting the end of the software industry, it has continued to thrive, with increased R&D spending, higher investment in innovation, and hiring demand outpacing supply.” said Oracle General Counsel Dorian Daley in an emailed statement.

At one point, Oracle demanded $8.8 billion from Google in damages. The lower court has not yet ruled on what amount, if any, Google would be commanded to pay should Google’s loss become permanent.


more recommended stories

  • Why Mueller report doesn’t signify end of Russia probe

    On Friday, the special counsel Robert.

  • Trump supporters celebrate end of Robert Mueller’s Russia investigation

    President Donald Trump’s supporters celebrated the.

  • Mueller report: what happens next

    The special counsel Robert Mueller on.

  • Robert Mueller has turned in his full report on the Russia investigation

    The special counsel Robert Mueller has.

  • Photos: California’s super bloom of flowers can be seen from space

    The hot, dry hillsides of Southern.

  • Tijuana residents stealing concertina barbed wire on border for homes

    Voluminous bundles of concertina wire strung.

  • The Cinderella team that rocked March Madness the year you were born

    The 2010 NCAA tournament was defined.

  • Dog dies in cargo hold of Air France flight

    A dog died on an Air.

  • State’s Pompeo jokes Trump may fire him via tweet as rumors swirl

    Secretary of State Mike Pompeo made.

  • WHERE ARE THEY NOW: The cast of 'Pretty Little Liars'

    Lucy Hale, Ashley Benson, Shay Mitchell,.

  • Ethiopian Airlines and Lion Air crashes similarities

    Boeing has come under scrutiny after.

  • New Zealand attorney general backtracks on semi-automatic weapons ban

    David Parker, the attorney general of.

  • New Zealand terror attacks: 50 dead, suspect identified as Brenton Tarrant

    The death toll for the deadly.

  • Watch Ryan Moore score a hole-in-one at the par 3 17th at Sawgrass

    Ryan Moore just nailed one of.

  • I tried Every Man Jack’s activated charcoal skin-care line — here’s what it’s like

    Insider Picks writes about products and.

  • Where to buy the new Adidas Ultra Boost 19

    Insider Picks writes about products and.

  • A photographer captured the last ten years his parents spent together, and the heartbreaking photos provide an intimate look at enduring love and loss

    Fine Arts photographer Paddy Summerfield’s series.

  • Cristiano Ronaldo brought Juventus back from the dead, beating Atletico 3-0

    Before a ball had even been.

  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez more famous than top Republicans, Trump cabinet

    New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is.

  • Here are the finance executives charged in the college-admissions cheating scandal

    Manuel A. Henriquez is the cofounder,.

  • FDA to finish rules on e-cigarettes sales before Gottlieb resigns

    The US Food and Drug Administration.

  • The most stunning photos from this week’s news

    This week’s news included stunning shots.

  • Video suggests protesters set aid truck on fire at Venezuela border

    Last month, an US-backed effort to.

  • Kevin Durant, Kyrie Irving free agency rumors are mounting

    Some believe that Durant may only.

  • Americans will need a visa to visit 22 European countries by 2021

    Travel to Europe won’t be so.

  • Air freight, a key measure of trade, sees biggest drop since 2015

    Air freight has been weakening since.

  • Elizabeth Warren call to break up Amazon, Google is a real threat

    It’s been a long time since.

  • Trump’s rhetoric casts doubt on how he responds to natural disasters

    President Donald Trump and the first.

  • The internet reacts to Mark Zuckerberg’s new privacy-focused Facebook

    On Tuesday, Mark Zuckerberg published a.

  • Steam blocks ‘Rape Day’ game release due to ‘unknown costs and risks’

    Steam, the most popular platform for.

  • American Eagle exec says brand primed to capitalize on store closings

    Teen-focused brand American Eagle, which also.

  • Self-driving cars worse at detecting people with dark skin, study says

    A new study from the Georgia.