House Democrats overplayed their hand to get the full Mueller report

The war between the White House and Congress hit a flash point this week, when both sides took drastic measures in their fight over the special counsel Robert Mueller’s unredacted report in the Russia investigation.

The Democratic-led House Judiciary Committee voted on Wednesday to hold Attorney General William Barr in contempt of Congress for failing to meet this week’s deadline to turn over the unredacted report and its underlying evidence.

In turn, the White House — acting on Barr’s advice — invoked executive privilege over the entire report, the underlying evidence, and all other material related to the report that Congress has subpoenaed so far.

The move set the stage for what’s likely to be a lengthy court fight between the executive and legislative branches.

It also laid bare how Democrats overplayed their hand in trying to get the full Mueller report, and how it’s coming back to bite them.

Read more: Trump just walked back his claim that there was ‘no obstruction’ in the Mueller probe in a big way

Robert Mueller.
Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call

Justice Department officials most recently offered to allow 12 lawmakers and two of each of their staffers to view a minimally redacted version of the report. They also said lawmakers and staffers could keep any notes they took of the document.

Democrats shot down the offer. Instead, they pushed for the full judiciary and intelligence committees — and three of each member’s staffers — to view the entire report, underlying evidence, and grand jury material.

After the DOJ refused, the judiciary committee began voting to hold Barr in contempt, and Trump retaliated by invoking executive privilege over the Mueller report.

Following Trump’s privilege assertion, the likely next step for Congress will be to go to court and obtain a legal declaration saying the claim is without merit.

But Frank Bowman, a law professor at the University of Missouri, told INSIDER that “even though the breadth of Trump’s executive privilege claim shows it’s transparently invalid, the objective is to make Congress jump through a bunch of hoops in the courts, which will be a slow process. It’s a stall.”

Ultimately, Bowman predicted, the privilege claim will likely be struck down.

“This assertion is a blanket denial of Congress’ ability to inquire about executive misconduct,” he said. “I can’t imagine the judiciary would ultimately put up with this.”

Read more: The Republican-led Senate Intelligence Committee reportedly subpoenaed Donald Trump Jr. to answer questions about the Russia probe

President Donald Trump in the Diplomatic Reception Room of the White House on March 25, 2019.
Michael Reynolds – Pool/Getty Images

But that doesn’t mean Congress will come out on top.

Mitchel Sollenberger, a politics professor at the University of Michigan, told INSIDER that more than anything else, he was shocked at the speed with which House Democrats moved to hold Barr in contempt.

The last time Congress held an attorney general in contempt was in 2012, when 17 Democrats joined the Republican majority after Eric Holder repeatedly refused to turn over documents related to Operation “Fast and Furious.”

Ultimately, a federal judge tossed out the charges, and Holder avoided severe penalties. But nearly a year passed before Congress went from negotiating with the DOJ to moving forward on a contempt citation against Holder.

In Barr’s case, as House Judiciary Committee ranking member Doug Collins noted on Wednesday, “[Democrats] have moved from request to contempt vote in only 43 days, and yet the Justice Department is still at the negotiating table — waiting for Democrats to arrive in good faith.”

“There’s a dance that goes on between the executive branch and legislative branch when it comes to getting documents and testimony,” Sollenberger said. “This dance hadn’t even entered its first move, so I’m flabbergasted at where we are right now.”

Read more: New York is poised to pass 2 bills that would make it easier for Congress to get Trump’s taxes and weaken his pardon power

FILE PHOTO: Rep. Jerrold Nadler speaks to the media as he arrives on Capitol Hill in Washington

Meanwhile, to get access to sensitive information contained in the report, like grand jury material, the judiciary committee could go to court.

“But if this goes to court, there’s a strong chance the judge would say the DOJ was being pretty reasonable with its offers,” Michael Stern, a former lawyer who served as senior counsel to the House of Representatives from 1996 to 2004, told INSIDER.

He added: “It’s logical for the DOJ to offer a limited look while it conducts a more thorough review of the redactions. And it’s hard for Democrats to argue why they didn’t at least take up the initial offer to view a less redacted version of the report before moving forward with contempt.”

Stern described executive privilege as a “balancing test” between the interests of the executive and legislative branches.

“The judge would likely say, ‘OK, there are issues of executive privilege here, but you want me to try to resolve that when you haven’t even taken up the offer of looking at the material to explain why you need it,'” he added. “So they’d probably end up telling lawmakers to do that first, before asking for more.”

In other words, Democrats could spend months, possibly years, tangled up in the legal process and end up with the same choice they were given to begin with.

The only way to circumvent that, experts say, is for congressional Democrats to argue they need access to the full report and grand jury material because they’re relevant to impeachment proceedings. But senior Democrats are pumping the brakes on impeachment from fear of political backlash.

In all, from both a political and legal standpoint, if Democrats’ “interest is simply getting the information for further investigation, they didn’t handle this well,” Stern said.


more recommended stories

  • Epstein had foreign passport to protect him from ‘hijackers’: lawyers

    Jeffrey Epstein, the financier recently charged.

  • Elon Musk’s sister runs passionflix video streaming for romance book movies

    Elon Musk may be the most.

  • The best competing Prime Day 2019 sales — Walmart, Target, eBay, & more

    After four years running, Amazon’s retail.

  • How to set up a custom voicemail greeting on a Galaxy S10

    One of the first things you.

  • I always wanted to be a millionaire and it was nothing like I expected

    Hansson at work. via Basecamp Facebook.

  • Apple AirPod Earbuds Deal: Save $14 to $20 on Amazon Prime Day 2019

    Truly wireless earbuds like Apple’s AirPods.

  • APPLY NOW: Insider Inc. is hiring editorial and video fellows and more

    Insider Inc. has a number of.

  • Video shows men in an over-crowded facility yelling “no shower”

    A video taken and posted on.

  • Sharp and McCann show the future of British boxing is fun and flashy

    02 ARENA, LONDON — Red hot.

  • Jeffrey Epstein launched PR campaign after 2008 sex abuse allegations

    Jeffrey Epstein launched a PR campaign.

  • Prime Day 2019 KitchenAid Stand Mixer deals — sale predictions

    There are some things that never.

  • The best vacuum deals we expect to see during Prime Day 2019

    No matter how diligently you clean.

  • Asylum seeker describes baby’s death from poor medical care in ICE custody

    WASHINGTON (AP) — A Guatemalan mother.

  • A new holding center for migrant children opened in rural Texas

    CARRIZO SPRINGS, Texas (AP) — A.

  • Video seems to show Trump embrace staffer who says he forcibly kissed

    President Donald Trump’s attorneys were accused.

  • How to back up photos from an iPhone with iCloud storage

    If you’re someone who loves taking.

  • Famous people who have flown on Jeffrey Epstein’s private plane

    The financier Jeffrey Epstein, the convicted.

  • 9 questions you should ask flight attendants next time you fly

    Getting on a plane is a.

  • DOJ to swap interpreters with videos at immigration hearings

    The Department of Justice is planning.

  • Federal court ruled against bikini baristas at Washington coffee bars

    Women serving coffee at the Hillbilly.

  • Greece election: Conservative party beats left-wing prime minister

    In his concession speech, Mr Tsipras.

  • Photos of US Navy guided missile destroyer USS Jason Dunham

    During the final days of June,.

  • No-deal Brexit: Boris Johnson to be hit by dozens of new Tory rebels

    LONDON — Dozens more Conservative MPs.

  • Turkey is last major Islamic state not to stand up for China’s Muslims

    In recent months, a wave of.

  • PHOTOS: Sophie Turner’s wedding dress with husband Joe Jonas

    Sophie Turner and Joe Jonas had.

  • The winners and losers of the opening days of NBA free agency

    The NBA offseason has been fast.

  • European stocks are jumping as traders bet on loose Fed policy, while US markets break for the Fourth of July

    Ritzau Scanpix Denmark/Reuters US markets were.

  • Megan Rapinoe shuts down critics: ‘I think I’m extremely American’

    Megan Rapinoe has been no stranger.

  • Steve Irwin and son fed the same crocodile 15 years apart

    Steve Irwin’s 15-year-old son Bob is.

  • Serena Williams will wait before giving Meghan Markle parenting advice

    Serena Williams says she will wait.

  • Stocks are dropping on trade-war jitters after Trump threatens another $4 billion in tariffs on EU goods

    Assoicated Press/Alex Brandon US stocks slid.

  • I went to Times Square to see why tourists love it

    Growing up on Long Island, I.