Masculinity is having a moment

Men are under attack. Everything that makes masculinity sacred — valor, honor, chivalry, leadership — is under siege. 

What else could explain a recent commercial for a Gillette razor blade suggesting that men should spare each other from bullying and hold each other accountable for sexual harassment? How else should we interpret guidelines recently issued by the American Psychological Association to help therapists more effectively work with their male clients by better understanding the social pressure they face to be so-called real men? 

Masculinity is having a moment. There’s a movement for a more expressive, more inclusive definition of manhood, but its critics see something more nefarious. If you listen to Piers Morgan or New York Times columnist Ross Douthat, skeptics of the Gillette ad and APA guidelines, you might mistake that movement as an assault waged by feminists and liberals when it’s really a quiet revolution staged in large part by men of diverse backgrounds who are tired of living by the very narrow, unforgiving standards of stereotypical masculinity. 

Morgan lashed out at the Gillette commercial, now viewed more than 26 million times, by calling it “pathetic global assault on masculinity.” Douthat described the APA guidelines as the “latest flashpoint in the culture war over the sexes,” failing to mention that they’re based on years of professional insight and expertise, and using paper-thin ideals of manhood espoused by Victorian-era novelists as his righteous foil. Let’s also not forget social media personality Graham Allen, who saw the Gillette ad then promptly posted a family photo on Instagram of himself and his sons holding guns with the caption “practicing our ‘toxic masculinity'”. 

The fear you’ve heard from skeptics of this moment is the fear of not knowing what lies beyond stereotypical masculinity — and what might emerge in its place. We associate numerous traits with different versions of manhood, including physical strength, courage, wisdom, stoicism, virtuousness, dominance, and wealth. Some of these are worthy attributes that help men excel in personal, social, and professional roles. They’re also frankly what many people, regardless of gender, aspire to become. 

But the normative script that many boys and men feel obliged to follow at home, on the playground, at school, on a sports team, at work, and elsewhere can distort or warp their pursuit of admirable character traits. Women become objects, emotional vulnerability becomes a dangerous liability, and boys and men become subject to social or physical violence if they try to break free from or subvert the expectations of masculinity. 

Fredric Rabinowitz, a clinical psychologist and professor at the University of Redlands who worked with 30 different psychologists on the APA guidelines for more than a decade, says he didn’t find the recent backlash too surprising. He knows that even talking about masculinity can prompt defensiveness. When you question whether we’re giving boys and men healthy role models and messages, that looks to some like criticizing manhood itself. 

“Part of what’s happened, and it probably relates to the politics of this country right now, is that some people feel like their sense of self is being taken away by just talking about masculinity,” he says. (Douthat, he says, didn’t chat with him before penning his column.) 

“Some people feel like their sense of self is being taken away by just talking about masculinity.”

Rabinowitz has well-informed insight into the male psyche: He’s run a therapy group for men who “want a place to be honest with themselves and others” for three decades. He’s worked with hundreds of male clients in individual and group therapy. Rabinowitz sees men who don’t necessarily think about their masculinity but nevertheless feel the pressure of living up to certain norms, like being seen as strong and independent. Sometimes they feel trapped by cultural and self-imposed expectations of what it means to be a man. 

Rabinowitz works with men who don’t cry in front of others, men who can’t connect with their partners, men who refuse to see a doctor until it’s too late, and men who deal with frustration by turning to violence. Often, Rabinowitz can trace their suffering back to unfair expectations they’ve embraced or heard: Only wimps cry. Only weak men are sensitive. Only losers ask for help. 

Admitting that men hear, internalize, and act on these “toxic” messages — to their physical, psychological, and spiritual detriment — isn’t a condemnation of men as a gender. Instead, it’s the start of a personal and cultural reckoning that can liberate men from the pressure to constantly perform someone else’s idea of masculinity. 

It’s foolish to pretend that these ideas don’t hold men back from their full humanity. It’s also dangerous to deny that they affect men differently. A gay black teen, a Honduran undocumented immigrant, and a white man with a disability are all at the mercy of harsh cultural and social norms, yet how they respond depends on their unique life experiences. 

If critics of the healthy masculinity movement can’t imagine what good could come of it, try considering this feminist’s vision of where it could lead us. Imagine a world in which the majority of men could, for example, cultivate physical strength and feel no shame for expressing vulnerability; take pride in their work without resenting their breadwinner wife; and feel confident as they seek help for depression. 

A more generous, more humane world doesn’t steal a man’s masculine identity but makes room for it to be expansive. It’s not just “radical” feminists who envision such a world. It’s what many men have advocated for over the past few decades. 

Men like sociologist Michael Kimmel, advocate Gary Barker, activist Tony Porter, and author and educator Jackson Katz have long spoken about the potential and real harms of exacting masculinity. While psychologist Jordan Peterson, known for preaching about the importance of patriarchy and male dominance, gets splashy media coverage, these men do the quiet work of changing minds and lives, one boy and man at a time. 

Even famous men like Justin Baldoni, Michael Phelps, and Ryan Reynolds, are defying the stigma attached to male vulnerability by openly discussing their emotional well-being and mental health. 

Yet many men feel they can’t safely reject certain masculine norms. The problem, says Rabinowitz, is that masculine stereotypes often influence how men see themselves. Some feel their manhood must be earned and proven; they notice that men who do otherwise can lose their status. So they guard their masculine identity vigilantly and pursue what they’ve been told will make them a real man.   

“Right now having more means having more money, status, and admiration, but at some point having more might mean, ‘Wow, I can feel all my feelings,'” says Rabinowitz. He wants men to enjoy the full range of human emotions, strong relationships, and self-confidence. 

But Rabinowitz also doesn’t expect men to immediately embrace that idea, nor does he cajole men into opening up the first time he sees them. Instead, he tries to create a non-judgmental space in which they can be their true selves. And that’s really what the APA guidelines advised psychologists: See your male patients for who they really are, not for who society expects them to be. 

If critics of healthy masculinity don’t want the same thing for every man, then they don’t deserve to be the loudest voices in the room.   

Uploads%252fvideo uploaders%252fdistribution thumb%252fimage%252f85736%252fd1ac6388 e773 4428 ae00 8d14dcd78fd1.jpg%252foriginal.jpg?signature=sebb xqrwrgpuhx2t6mju ihecc=&source=https%3a%2f%2fblueprint api production.s3.amazonaws

Source link

more recommended stories

  • Teen YouTubers who faked a pregnancy apologize — and offer bad sex ed advice

    Two teenage YouTubers were the subject.

  • Amazon devices, Philips juicers, Microsoft tablets, Kenwood mixers, and more on sale for April 18 in the UK

    The bank holiday weekend is almost.

  • Microsoft refused to sell facial recognition tech to law enforcement

    The potential for abuse of facial.

  • Google Pay can import airline miles, reward points, and more from Gmail now

    KRAKOW, POLAND – 2018/08/27: Fifty and.

  • ‘Game of Thrones’ premiere featured cameos from ‘It’s Always Sunny’ and ‘Silicon Valley’

    Spoiler warning: If you’re not caught.

  • 3 ways to combat climate change according to young activists

    Young people have a lot more.

  • Internet Explorer exploit lets hackers steal data even if you never it

    Even if you never open Internet.

  • Juul sets up a web portal for narcing on vaping teens

    Don’t be a bad teen.Image: Suzanne.

  • Mike Gravel’s campaign is proof that more politicians need meme tutors

    In the age of surrealist memes.

  • Noah Centineo plays an insufferable jerk in ‘The Perfect Date’: Review

    The following is a spoiler-free review.

  • A guide to roasting Bran Stark in ‘Game of Thrones’ Season 8

    sBran Stark sucks, but you don’t.

  • Instagram cracks down on ‘inappropriate’ content

    Instagram is making changes to its.

  • How did NASA create its own pretty artificial auroras? Rockets, of course.

    These artificial auroras are arguably as.

  • Don’t hold your breath for that 16-inch MacBook Pro

    Apple’s 16-  or 16.5-inch MacBook Pro.

  • K-pop Twitter can’t tell which way BTS’ Jimin is facing in this new video clip

    There’s nothing the internet loves more.

  • Shadows Die Twice’ and difficulty vs. accessibility

    For anyone who’s been paying attention.

  • Watch hilarious ‘Game of Thrones’ sketches from ‘Saturday Night Live’

    Jon Snow may know nothing, but.

  • Best wireless charging mats 2019 (RIP AirPower, we hardly knew you)

    The Choetech wireless charging pad is.

  • Snapchat gets upgrade with gaming platform and new features

    Snapchat is trying to stay alive.

  • Elon Musk is still Tesla CEO — for now

    Tesla CEO Elon Musk had his.

  • Lincoln Aviator SUV returns with 28-speaker sound system

    Disclosure Every product here is independently.

  • ‘Game of Thrones’ star Emilia Clarke describes what it’s like to survive a brain haemorrhage

    Emilia Clarke recently penned an op-ed.

  • The three most popular Netflix shows in the U.S.

    HighSpeedInternet looked at the top shows.

  • Best and worst April Fools jokes from big tech companies in 2019

    Big tech companies continued the tradition.

  • Facebook will give you more info about why certain posts show up in your News Feed

    Facebook is adding a feature to.

  • This massive online course sale is meant to help you live your best life

    Your time is valuable and limited.

  • Tom Hiddleston’s Chinese Centrum ad is a real wild ride

    It was brought to the internet’s.

  • Dad delivers impromptu performance of ‘Ave Maria’ for his daughter at Disney World

    There are some things in life.

  • GoFundMe donates to GoFundMe that’s trolling another GoFundMe

    We forgive you if you’re feeling.

  • Stephen Colbert tears into NASA for its female spacesuit debacle

    In case you needed any evidence.

  • The Fire HD 8 is on sale for Prime Members for $30 off on Amazon

    Just to let you know, if.

  • Best tax software for small business owners 2019

    Tax software that’s capable of tackling.