U.S. appeals court blocks Trump administration birth control exemptions

(Reuters) – A federal appeals court on Friday blocked the Trump administration from enforcing new rules allowing employers to obtain exemptions from an Obamacare requirement they provide health insurance that covers women’s birth control.

FILE PHOTO: An illustration picture shows a woman holding a birth control pill at her home in Nice January 3, 2013. REUTERS/Eric Gaillard

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia upheld a nationwide injunction that blocked the implementation of rules allowing employers with religious and moral objections to seek exemptions from the 2010 healthcare law’s requirement.

The three-judge panel agreed with Democratic state attorneys general from Pennsylvania and New Jersey pursuing the case that the rules issued by the U.S. Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor and Treasury had “serious substantive problems.”

The lawsuit was one of several by Democratic state attorneys general challenging the rules, which targeted a requirement in the Affordable Care Act, or Obamacare, former Democratic President Barack Obama’s signature domestic policy achievement.

The contraceptive mandate required employer-provided health insurance include coverage for birth control with no co-payment.

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro on Twitter said the ruling would protect women’s access to contraceptive care.

Republican President Donald Trump’s administration itself has estimated up to 126,400 women nationally would lose contraceptive coverage due to their employers taking advantage of the exemptions.

Kelly Laco, spokeswoman for the U.S. Justice Department, which defended the rules in court, said it was disappointed. “Religious organizations should not be forced to violate their mission and deeply-held beliefs,” she said.

The appellate ruling upheld a nationwide injunction issued in January by a federal judge in Philadelphia. Another judge in California has blocked the rules’ enforcement in 14 states and the District of Columbia.

In Friday’s decision, U.S. Circuit Judge Patty Shwartz, writing for the panel, said the administration lacked good cause to forgo a requirement to provide the public notice and the chance to comment on interim versions of the rules it adopted in 2017.

The administration had cited an urgent need to alleviate the harm faced by employers with religious objections.

But Shwartz said its “desire to address the purported harm to religious objections does not ameliorate the need to follow appropriate procedures.”

She said government agencies showed a “lack of open-mindedness” when they later adopted similar, final rules in 2018, which were also not authorized by Obamacare.

A nationwide preliminary injunction preventing the rules’ enforcement was necessary, she said, to protect the states from against the potential costs they would face if women’s employers refused to provide insurance that covered birth control.

Reporting by Nate Raymond in Boston; editing by Tom Brown

Source

more recommended stories

  • AstraZeneca’s Imfinzi misses main goal of advanced lung cancer study

    FILE PHOTO: A sign is seen.

  • AstraZeneca diabetes drug shows promise in heart failure

    (Reuters) – AstraZeneca (AZN.L) made strides.

  • Study prompts call for lower fluoride consumption by pregnant women

    (Reuters Health) – Adding fluoride to.

  • CDC investigates lung illnesses linked to e-cigarette use

    FILE PHOTO: A man vapes outside.

  • E.coli in water forces Tokyo to cancel swimming at Paratriathlon World Cup

    TOKYO (Reuters) – High levels of.

  • E.coli risk forces Tokyo to cancel swim events at Paratriathlon World Cup

    TOKYO (Reuters) – High levels of.

  • First two Ebola cases confirmed in Congo’s South Kivu – officials

    FILE PHOTO: Children look at a.

  • Surgical training programs not supportive of new parents

    (Reuters Health) – Surgical residents say.

  • Liver disease related to obesity and diabetes rising in U.S.

    (Reuters Health) – The only liver.

  • Ebola ‘no longer incurable’ as Congo trial finds drugs boost survival

    LONDON (Reuters) – Scientists are a.

  • Scientists hail promise of first effective Ebola treatments in Congo trial

    LONDON (Reuters) – Scientists are a.

  • China cuts 2019/20 corn use forecast by 2 million tonnes due to African swine fever

    Corn kernels are seen at a.

  • WHO says no new Ebola cases in Goma, vaccinates over 1,300

    FILE PHOTO: A young woman reacts.

  • Dengue death toll rises in Malaysia, number of cases close to double

    KUALA LUMPUR (Reuters) – Malaysia saw.

  • Amgen wins U.S. patent battle on arthritis drug Enbrel, thwarting Novartis

    (Reuters) – A U.S. judge on.

  • AstraZeneca’s Tagrisso helps lung cancer patients live longer: study

    (Reuters) – AstraZeneca Plc said on.

  • Study shows Apple devices in combo with apps could identify dementia

    FILE PHOTO: The new Apple iPhone.

  • Moving during early pregnancy may increase preterm birth risk

    (Reuters Health) – Moving to a.

  • Drug assistance programs offer little charity to uninsured

    (Reuters Health) – Many patients who.

  • In extreme heat, electric fans inadvisable unless it’s humid

    In extreme heat, electric fans may.

  • Trump administration considers September unveiling of healthcare plan: WSJ

    FILE PHOTO: U.S. President Donald Trump.

  • Bulgaria to compensate owners who cull pigs to help stamp out swine fever

    FILE PHOTO: A pig rests at.

  • Yellow lens glasses don’t improve drivers’ night vision

    (Reuters Health) – – Touted to.

  • U.S. FDA approves Daiichi Sankyo’s treatment for rare joint tumor

    (Reuters) – The U.S. Food and.

  • For some surgeries, hospital rankings not tied to better outcomes

    (Reuters Health) – When it comes.

  • Congo says Rwanda has closed border near Goma

    Congolese customs agents gather at the.

  • Pluristem gets positive results from radiation treatment trials

    TEL AVIV (Reuters) – Israel’s Pluristem Therapeutics.

  • Congress seeks briefing on potential threat to U.S. heparin supply

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Leaders of the.

  • U.S. judge blocks Medicaid work requirements in New Hampshire

    (Reuters) – A federal judge on.

  • Bernie Sanders visits Canadian pharmacy, talks drug prices

    WINDSOR, Ontario (Reuters) – U.S. Senator.

  • China detects African swine fever in pigs transported to Liaoning: Xinhua

    BEIJING (Reuters) – China detected African.

  • Sanofi ends partnership with Lexicon to develop diabetes drug

    FILE PHOTO: A logo of Sanofi.