India-Pakistan cricket row over army caps and politics in sport | Sport

The controversy around the Indian cricket team wearing military caps on the field to pay homage to its troops has reignited a decades-old debate over the mixing of politics with sports.

India‘s national side came under scrutiny for “militarising” the game after its players wore army camouflage caps during a match against Australia in the eastern Indian city of Ranchi.

The gesture, earlier this month, was in solidarity with the Indian paramilitary police officers killed in a suicide attack by a Pakistan-based group in the disputed Kashmir region and to raise donations for the National Defence Fund. 

But analysts and sports diplomacy experts questioned the Indian cricket team’s move, saying it did “no favours to either national security nor sport”.

“It’s fine to raise money for the troops as long as the fundraising happens off the field,” Mukul Kesavan, an Indian writer and historian, told Al Jazeera.

Pakistan, which came to the brink of war with India in the aftermath of the February bombing in the Pulwama district of Indian-administered Kashmir this year, criticised the Indian team for “politicising” the sport.

“We believe that cricket and sports should not be used for politics and we have said this very clearly,” the Pakistan Cricket Board chairman, Ehsan Mani, said while revealing that he had lodged a formal protest in a letter to the International Cricket Council (ICC).

“Their [India] credibility in the cricketing world has gone down very badly.”


An ICC spokesperson told Al Jazeera that the Indian cricket board – the BCCI – asked for prior approval to wear the olive-and-black caps “as part of a fundraising drive and in memory of soldiers, which was granted”.

“Given the fact that it happened in the aftermath of the India-Pakistan border skirmishing, it just seems pointed in a way that has no business on a cricket field,” said Kesavan.

J Simon Rofe, Global Diplomacy programme director at the University of London, said funds can be raised “without having an overt visual dimension”.

He referred to the annual ‘Pink Test’ supporting breast cancer and the World Cricket Tsunami Appeal match held in Melbourne in 2005.

“There are ways of expressing support for a good cause without it having overt military, let alone political connotations,” Rofe, author of Sport and Diplomacy: Games within Games, told Al Jazeera. 

Cricket and diplomacy nexus

Athletes, including cricketers, have used sport to make political and personal statements in the past.

According to ICC’s code of conduct, players and team officials are not permitted to convey political, religious or racial messages through clothing or equipment.

The ICC would have the final say in determining whether any such message is approved, the world body said.

In 2014, English cricketer Moeen Ali was banned from wearing “Free Gaza” and “Save Palestine” wristbands during a series against India.

Pakistan-born South African bowler Imran Tahir was sanctioned for revealing a T-shirt featuring the portrait of Pakistani singer-turned-preacher Junaid Jamshed, who died in a plane crash in 2016.

“You have two examples from the past already, where both Tahir and Ali were sanctioned for something similar,” PCB’s Mani said, urging the ICC to take strong action against the Indian cricket board.

But according to Rofe, “the BCCI is a significant diplomatic player and that’s really what’s at stake here”. 

“The agenda of the BCCI is significant to the ICC and the fact that you’ve got the Indian Premier League coming up with a lot of the world’s best players, the nexus of cricket and diplomacy is in India,” he said.

Sporting boycott

Boycotts and sanctions over political differences are common in international sport, especially at the highest level.

The United States boycotted the 1980 Moscow Olympics in protest of the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.

South Africa, during the Apartheid era, was subjected to a variety of sporting sanctions by major international governing bodies for its institutionalised racial segregation.

Athletes from Arab countries, which do not have diplomatic ties with Israel, often refuse to compete against Israeli opponents.

India, in an attempt to isolate Pakistan in the cricketing world in the wake of the Pulwama attack, urged the ICC to sever ties with countries from which “terrorism emanates”, a plea that was rejected by the ICC.

Pakistan and India are scheduled to play at the cricket World Cup in June in England, but there are growing calls within India to pull out.

“There’s always going to be politics in international sport … because people do feel strongly about the right to assert what they think is a political virtue, in the context of a sporting encounter,” added Kesavan.

Rofe echoed the argument, saying the idea that “sport and politics don’t mix is a myth”.

“Sport provides both the spectators and the athletes with a platform and some will take advantage of that for very good reasons and some will take advantage of it for covert or indeed, hostile reasons.”


more recommended stories

  • Trump imposes new sanctions on Iran, targets supreme leader | USA News

    US President Donald Trump signed an.

  • Italy’s Milan and Cortina win vote to host 2026 Winter Olympics | News

    Italy has won the rights the.

  • Australia’s national broadcaster takes police to court over raid | News

    Australia‘s national broadcaster has gone to.

  • ‘We’ve had enough’: Huge crowds in Prague demand PM Babis quit | Russia News

    Prague, Czech Republic – Massive crowds.

  • Qatar seek to upset Lionel Messi’s Argentina in Copa America | Qatar News

    Copa America guest teams Japan and.

  • Sudan protesters accept Ethiopia plan for political transition | News

    Sudanese protest leaders have said they.

  • Iran-US tensions: All the latest updates | USA News

    Fears of war between the United.

  • Guatemala survivors of wartime sexual violence fight for justice | News

    Guatemala City, Guatemala – Indigenous Maya Achi women.

  • Will the United States attack Iran? | USA

    Tensions between the United States and.

  • Regeni’s parents demand Italy again recall Cairo envoy: Report | Egypt News

    The family of Italian doctoral student.

  • Iran slams US as Trump says drone downing may have been a mistake | USA News

    President Donald Trump says he does.

  • FIFA Women’s World Cup 2019: The best moments so far | News

    This year’s FIFA Women’s World Cup is.

  • Erdogan: Egypt government should be tried over Morsi’s death | Egypt News

    Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has.

  • UK: Labour’s Jeremy Corbyn backs second Brexit referendum | News

    Jeremy Corbyn, the leader of Britain’s.

  • UN rights investigator to issue report on Khashoggi killing | Saudi Arabia News

    UN extrajudicial executions investigator, Agnes Callamard,.

  • Shanahan withdraws from consideration to be US defence secretary | Trump News

    Acting US Secretary of Defense Patrick.

  • Boeing crisis dominates Paris Air Show 2019 | France News

    Aircraft safety, trade wars and geopolitical.

  • ‘Systemic failure’ of UN ahead of military crackdown: Review | Myanmar News

    There was a “systemic failure” of.

  • Uzbekistan reforms: Activists demand more changes | Uzbekistan News

    Not long ago, Uzbekistan was described.

  • Guatemala arrests fugitive ex-military chief accused of genocide | News

    Guatemala City – Guatemalan police have.

  • Sudan civilians say military has lost their trust after violence | Sudan News

    A diplomatic flurry to build bridges.

  • Father’s Day: Who celebrates today, and why | USA News

    Father’s Day is being celebrated in.

  • Is Iran to blame for suspected attacks on Gulf tankers? | News

    Even in ordinary times, an attack.

  • Nigeria land struggle: Farmers fight over resources | Nigeria News

    Competition for resources between farmers and.

  • ‘Work until you die, or die working’: Workers strike in Brazil | Brazil News

    Sao Paulo, Brazil – Thousands of.

  • DRC Violence: Reprisal attacks between tribes | DR Congo News

    Renewed fighting between ethnic militia in.

  • ‘We brought it home’: Toronto Raptors scoop first NBA title | News

    Canada’s Toronto Raptors have won their.

  • Can tension in the Gulf be contained? | Iran

    Two tankers were damaged in the.

  • US Navy assists two tankers in Gulf of Oman after distress calls | News

    The US Navy’s Bahrain-based Fifth Fleet.

  • Trump official grilled over $8bn ’emergency’ arms sale to Saudis | USA News

    Washington, DC – A senior US.

  • 20 years of democracy: Has Nigeria changed for the better? | News

    Two decades ago, in a colourful.

  • Israel plans to entrench annexation of East Jerusalem: report | Israel News

    If current demographic trends continue, Jerusalem.