Trump’s ‘ultimate deal’ faces ultimate failure | Palestine

At a private gathering at the Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) in London on February 28, David Makovsky and Dennis Ross – two men with a deep understanding of the decades-long peace process between the Palestinians and Israelis – spoke frankly and at length about US President Donald Trump‘s “ultimate deal”.

Makovsky is an author and journalist who covered the often anguished twists and turns of the journey to reach the Oslo accords of 1993 and 1995. Ross was appointed President Bill Clinton’s Middle East envoy in the first Clinton administration and in that capacity helped to broker the Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, commonly referred to as Oslo II in 1995.

Both men are seen by critics – justifiably or not – as being sympathetic towards Israel: Makovsky is a senior fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy (WINEP) which is closely linked to the pro-Israeli lobby AIPAC; Ross, after leaving his post as envoy, returned to WINEP as a counsellor and distinguished fellow.

What was abundantly clear from their comments was that the peace deal, whose details remain a closely held secret, is doomed to failure. As Makovsky put it “if it was left to the advisers, they would say do not pursue this deal.” He added that the risk of failure was high and “every failure comes with a cost”.

This is the fourth attempt at a comprehensive peace deal and the cynicism on both sides, after decades of effort, is running higher than ever before. Ross noted that “both sides have lost faith”; without faith, he argued, there is no chance of a deal. “What has been completely lost is the sense that there is the possibility a deal can be reached. That possibility has to somehow be recreated.”

Resurrecting the peace process is a major challenge in itself, but what makes it even more difficult to achieve for the Trump administration is the fact that the triumvirate delegated with this mission – Trump’s son-in-law Kushner, Trump Organisation lawyer Jason Greenblatt and Trump campaign adviser David Friedman – is seen as closely linked to the illegal settler movement in the West Bank.

Kushner’s family foundation has funded a settlement. Friedman, Trump’s appointee as ambassador to Israel, has argued that the settlements, contrary to international law, are not illegal. Greenblatt, confounding experts as well as common sense, has decreed that the settlements are “not an obstacle to peace”.

In keeping with the president’s approach to foreign affairs, Kushner has eschewed the systems and structures that in normal times are used as essential tools of diplomacy. He shares his father-in-law’s egotistic view that he has no need for the machinery of government nor the thoughts of wiser and older Middle East experts. In his very limited world view, this is just another Manhattan real estate deal writ large.

Makovsky called the triumvirate’s approach “close-holed”; other practitioners see the obsession for secrecy and the refusal to consult knowledgeable Middle East peace negotiators as simply paranoid.

No wonder then that there is an absence of faith on the Palestinian side. Kushner seems to believe that his project, which Makovsky called “economy plus-plus”, will convince the Palestinian leadership to give up some, if not all, of their “hot button” issues in return for economic benefits. These core issues remain the right of return for refugees, borders based on the 1967 Green Line, security and occupied East Jerusalem as the capital of a viable Palestinian state.

The benefits that are supposed to flow, in Kushner’s mind, like water in the desert, will come in part from the largesse of the Gulf states, in particular, Saudi Arabia. He, of course, has a special relationship with the Saudi crown prince and de facto ruler Mohammed bin Salman (MBS). (The crown prince has boasted that he has Kushner “in his pocket” so the relationship may not be quite what Kushner thinks it is.)

However, the Saudis are not prepared to stump up unless the US does too. Given Trump’s erratic and unpredictable approach to foreign policy, there is no guarantee whatsoever that will happen, a point not lost at all on the Saudis.

While it is true that Israel has worked assiduously to gain the support of key Gulf leaders, who view it as a bulwark of support against Iran, Ross said that “Arab leaders will never say publicly to the Palestinians that you must accept the (Kushner) deal.”

In a best-case scenario, he said, Arab leaders could say “we have questions and reservations but this does form the basis for negotiations” – in other words, a starting point and nothing more. Then the strategy would be to get Europe on side. That would leave the Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas in a bind and in Ross’ opinion he would be “forced to come to the table.”

However, the only way that could work is if the key demands, the hot buttons, of the Palestinians are met in the plan. While virtually nothing else is known about the 50-page document that Kushner has prepared, it is clear that it does not address these demands in any meaningful way.

Makovsky expressed his concern that the deal was “set up for failure”, and that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “was counting on Abbas to say no”, thus delivering to the hard-right settlement parties the result they wanted after supporting his re-election bid.

With news that the Israeli attorney general will proceed to indict the prime minister on charges of fraud, bribery and breach of trust, the election itself has been thrown wide open. Trump and Kushner have intimated that “the deal of the century” will be released sometime after the election on April 9. But whereas before it would have tumbled out in a political space secure in Netanyahu’s re-election, now the deal faces uncertainty in Israel as well as the anger of the Palestinians.

No one who has given it much thought really expects the plan to do anything other than fail. But when seasoned veterans like Makovsky and Ross confirm that view, it is a safe bet that Trump, the self-proclaimed great dealmaker who fell flat on his face at the Vietnam summit, is set for a repeat performance in a fractious and volatile Middle East.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance. 


more recommended stories

  • Algerians rally for fourth consecutive week against ailing leader | News

    Tens of thousands of Algerians have.

  • What can we expect from Thailand’s March 24 vote? | Asia

    The people of northeast Thailand have.

  • US to see unprecedented spring flooding in coming weeks | News

    The stage is set for unprecedented.

  • Thailand votes: Young voters prepare for Sunday’s election | Thailand News

    Almost 52 million eligible voters in.

  • Pressure mounts as May heads to final EU summit before Brexit | Brexit

    London, United Kingdom – On Thursday, the.

  • Karadzic sentence increased to life for Bosnia genocide: UN | Former Yugoslavia News

    United Nations judges have ordered former.

  • Radovan Karadzic faces final verdict in war crimes case | Former Yugoslavia News

    United Nations appeals judges on Wednesday.

  • ‘Major humanitarian emergency’ after cyclone batters SE Africa | Mozambique News

    Cyclone winds and floods that swept.

  • India-Pakistan cricket row over army caps and politics in sport | Sport

    The controversy around the Indian cricket.

  • Alleged NZ mosque gunman ‘rational’, lawyer says after he’s fired | New Zealand News

    The Australian man accused of shooting.

  • Philippines officially out of the International Criminal Court | News

    The Philippines has officially withdrawn from the.

  • More than 100 detained in Nicaragua’s anti-government protests | Daniel Ortega News

    Managua, Nicaragua – Police have detained.

  • New Zealand mosque attacks: Who were the victims? | News

    They were teachers, engineers and accountants..

  • Australian senator egged after racist comments on New Zealand | New Zealand News

    A far-right Australian senator had to.

  • New Zealand terrorist attack suspect grins in court | News

    The Australian suspect arrested after dozens.

  • New Zealand mosque attacks: What we know so far | New Zealand News

    Two mosques in the city of.

  • Australia Aboriginals win right to sue for colonial land loss | News

    Sydney, Australia – The High Court.

  • ‘Arms are for hugs’: US students march to end gun violence | News

    Washington, DC – Hundreds of students have.

  • Colombia: March in favour of FARC peace accord | Colombia News

    Colombians have rallied in defence of.

  • Brexit vote: UK parliament rejects ‘no-deal’ option | UK News

    London, England – With just over.

  • Hamid Karzai: Taliban and the Afghan government should talk | Afghanistan News

    US officials and Taliban representatives have.

  • US Senate to vote on Saudi-Yemen war resolution | USA News

    The US Senate will vote on.

  • Confederate statue removed in North Carolina city | News

    A North Carolina city removed a.

  • Confederate statue removed in North Carolina city | News

    A North Carolina city removed a.

  • Mahathir says government considering future of Malaysia Airlines | Malaysia News

    The Malaysian government is considering whether.

  • DRC’s Bemba seeks $77m in compensation from ICC | DR Congo News

    Jean-Pierre Bemba, a former vice president and.

  • India-Pakistan railway: Samjhauta Express train service restored | Pakistan News

    The Samjhauta Express also called the.

  • Serb Chetnik gathering in Bosnia’s Visegrad raises alarm | News

    A gathering of supporters of the.

  • Investigators at Ethiopian Airlines crash site look for answers | Ethiopia

    An Ethiopian Airlines passenger jet traveling.

  • Rival rallies held in Caracas as Venezuela crisis intensifies | News

    Thousands of people have once again.

  • Is enough being done to stop misinformation online? | Social media

    “Fake news” is a common cry.

  • Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka: ‘Patriarchy is bad for everybody’ | United Nations

    While the world is electing more.