When Is It Time to Fire an Employee?

Use these three tests to decide if it’s time to terminate a staffer.


4 min read

This story appears in the
December 2018

issue of
Entrepreneur. Subscribe »

Q: My company is small, and every team member seems necessary. How do I know if I need to fire one? –Ben P., Florida

Nothing is worse than having to fire an employee. But for business owners, there is nothing more important than removing employees that are disruptive to your mission. This is a lesson I’ve learned over and over again. When I’ve leaned on kindness and given people the benefit of the doubt, it’s often led to a greater investment of time and resources spent on employees who, ultimately, were just not worth it. 

There’s a popular axiom that suggests you should hire slow and fire fast. That’s great in theory, but I’ve never found it especially practical. Hiring slow can cause you to miss out on potentially valuable employees (if they’re that good, others will want them, too), and firing fast can turn your business into the type of corporate morass people avoid. Instead, firing should be about knowing the principles of your business and making sure you establish standards to measure the value and purpose of every employee — whether you have one or 100. 

Related: That ‘Bad’ Interviewee You Just Talked to May Be the Perfect Match for Your Job Opening

How do you measure value? Figure that out before you hire (or fire!) anyone. Every business will do this a little differently, but across mine, we’ve learned to assess employees based on these three values:

Value #1: Productivity

How much is this employee contributing? 

A productive employee accomplishes the goals set by the employer — and then some. Minimum output is rarely enough. It’s why so many small businesses fold within three years. An attitude of “Here’s what you should do and that’s it” puts your business on the fast track to failure. Instead, give employees baseline expectations that will help keep the business afloat, but make it clear that you expect more. Going above and beyond will give you a competitive advantage, and doing more is what’s needed to succeed. 

Related: After Realizing He’d Hired All the Wrong People, This Food Startup Founder Hit Reset

Value #2: Efficiency and Capabilities

How are they making our operation better?

Growth isn’t always about what an employee takes on. Sometimes it’s about responsibilities they remove in order to create new efficiencies. If your employee is not making your life significantly easier (and increasing your bandwidth) or adding capabilities that were previously lacking, then you should really question their purpose.

Value #3: Personal Values

Do they make work enjoyable?

The emotional value of an employee is just as important as more quantifiable business metrics. Respect, communication and compassion might not show up on the bottom line, but they make a big difference with internal and external interaction and growth. If their personality doesn’t convey what you want, it’s an added vulnerability in the uphill battle of entrepreneurship. 

So when do you fire? When an employee can’t fulfill all three of the core values. If even one is missing, it’s too much of a risk to keep that staffer. And if all are fulfilled, it’s your job to put that employee in a position to succeed, love their work and feel well-compensated. 

Related: Millennials Are Old News: What Does Generation Z Want From Work?

Firing an employee will never be easy, but the process of evaluation doesn’t have to be hard. Set your values, make them clear, provide opportunities, and you’ll be more likely to build—and keep—a team that gives you the best chance to succeed. 

Source link

more recommended stories

  • How to Build Philanthropy Into Your Budget — Even If You’re Not Google

    Big-name companies like Google are doubling.

  • 10 Questions to Ask Before Committing to a Business Partner

    If you can get someone to.

  • Model 3 Gets Bad Report Card, Leading to Drop for Tesla Stock

    Plus, more signs of a sputtering.

  • 4 Ways to Successfully Turn Your Day Job into a #SideHustle That Earns You #PassiveIncome from #ThePowerofPassiveIncome

    Find out which key moves you.

  • J.M. Smucker Is Up, But Rest of Stock Market Soft After Minutes of Last Fed Meeting Released

    The stock market wasn’t sure what.

  • The 10 Most Reliable Ways to Fund a Startup

    Every funding decision is a complex.

  • The Most Important Career Lessons Are the Ones You Learn From Your Mistakes

    Instead of being embarrassed by your.

  • 7 Steps to a Perfectly Written Business Plan

    February 20, 2019 7 min read.

  • Must-Reads for List-Makers, Disrupters, and Social Entrepreneurs

    Inspired by our own personal goals.

  • 3 Fast Ways To Get Good Press

    Whether you’re a publicist or a.

  • 9 Questions to Ask Candidates’ References

    February 18, 2019 5 min read.

  • Are Your Goals Too Small? Here’s How to Know.

    See your life transform by setting.

  • 5 Partnership Lessons From Bill Belichick and Tom Brady

    Neither would be wearing so many.

  • Learning From Kevin Hart’s Social Media Mistakes

    He lost his gig at the.

  • Breaking Through on the PGA Tour After 187 Tries

    PGA Tour player Ken Duke shares.

  • Learn How to Practice Mindfulness at Work for Less Than $40

    Make the ancient, stress-relieving discipline more.

  • Why Your Next Startup Should Focus on Healthcare

    Breakdowns exist in the healthcare system,.

  • Market Up as Government Shutdown Averted, but FAANG Stocks Still Down

    The government shutdown drama is over.

  • 9 Business Ideas Under $1,000 You Can Run From Anywhere

    February 15, 2019 11 min read.

  • How to Make Your Wealth Last for Generations

    Hone your financial literacy and sustain.

  • Bed Bath & Beyond (Up 49 Percent This Year) Continues to Rise, but the Market Falls Flat

    Stocks were not feeling the love.

  • This Startup Raised $30 Million. Now, Its Founder Is Accused of Fraud.

    This promising Mexican startup closed its.

  • Corporate America Needs Understand These 4 Keys to Working With Millennials

    Millennials have a bad reputation that.

  • Government Shutdown and Trade Talks Still in Limbo but Market Up Slightly

    The stock market didn’t seem overly.

  • Jack Dorsey Picks Elon Musk as ‘Most Exciting’ User, Amazon Buys Eero and Prices Spike at Whole Foods (60-Second Video)

    Here are three things entrepreneurs should.

  • This CEO Says That Second-Guessing Your Business Is Natural

    The big decision for this Canadian.

  • The Government Shutdown Wasn’t So Bad for the Stock Market — But Avoiding a Shutdown Would Be Even Better

    The Entrepreneur Index™ was up big.

  • Mars Trip Could Cost You Less Than $500K or Even $100K

    The prices would be ‘low enough.

  • Chipotle Shoots for the Stars, Hires Oscar Winner to Produce Ad

    The burrito chain the had biggest.

  • Could These Companies Be the Next $1 Billion Unicorns?

    A new study looks ahead at.

  • Stop Hitting the Snooze Button and Start Intentionally Building Your Life and Business

    Don’t beat yourself up for hitting.

  • Get Exclusive Access to Silicon Valley Trailblazers for Less Than $10

    The CEOs of Redfin, Nextdoor, SurveyMonkey,.