If 5G Networking Is a U.S. Intel Priority, Should It Receive U.S. Intel Funding?

David P. Goldman, China policy expert and frequent guest on Breitbart News Tonight, offered what he described as a “modest proposal” in an article published Thursday at PJ Media: If 5G wireless is so clearly a concern for U.S. intelligence, a portion of the intelligence budget should be invested in creating an American competitor to China’s dominant Huawei corporation.

Much of Goldman’s effort was focused on demonstrating that 5G wireless communications are one of the top priorities for the American intelligence community, which he argued has spent a great deal of money on far less valuable pursuits. 

One of the understated reasons for competing with China for 5G dominance is that China could use the technology to prevent American agencies from conducting the one kind of intelligence gathering it still does extremely well after a disastrous eight years under President Barack Obama:

The techie equivalent of the Oklahoma Land Rush is underway to embed quantum communications in the new 5G broadband networks under construction around the world. The Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei along with British, South Korean, Japanese and other research groups are competing to make data transmission and voice or video calls hack-proof. The technology is proven, so it’s only a matter of time before the screens at the National Security Agency go dark. Quantum communications shift the balance of power in communications to the defense. It doesn’t matter whether you have powerful computers, for example, quantum computers, because you destroy the signal simply by observing it.

That, I believe, explains the furor in America’s spook world over Huawei’s prospective domination of 5G telecommunications. The spooks claim that Huawei will use back doors in its hardware to steal everyone’s data. No doubt Chinese intelligence will use every opportunity at its disposal to steal data, but that’s beside the point: No-one will be able to hack the next generation of data networks. Since the U.S. has a decisive advantage in SIGINT, China is the relative winner if no-one can read the world’s email.

Goldman also touched on the importance of 5G networking to the fusion of electronic intelligence and military hardware that will define the coming era of “hyperwar,” to use the term favored by increasingly nervous American and European analysts:

The real disaster in China’s domination of 5G isn’t data hacking. 5G is the thin end of a technological wedge that includes the Internet of Things, factory-floor automation, autonomous vehicles, and coordination of drone swarms. The last item on the list might be the most important development in warfare since the ballistic missile. A very large number of small, cheap drones acting in concert through Artificial Intelligence systems may be able to defeat everything that presently flies. If China controls 5G technology, it is all the more likely to prevail in the spinoff technologies.

With that in mind, Goldman suggested shifting $70 billion of the U.S. intelligence budget to research and development for 5G technology, matching Huawei’s R&D budget over the past decade and leaving the CIA with $10 billion to fund its “vast, unaudited empire that no one can monitor, let alone control.”

The prospect of CIA money pouring into network development might disturb some people, but after all, the Internet began as a defense and intelligence project. The Chinese would certainly have a field day with the prospect of money budgeted for the intelligence community flowing to American telecom companies instead, especially after the Trump administration warned the rest of the world about the dangers of Huawei working with Chinese intelligence. A little creative accounting might be in order for public relations purposes. Fortunately, Washington specializes in creative accounting.

One of Goldman’s key points was that American policymakers asked Western companies to avoid Huawei for security reasons but offered no real alternative, a rather astounding error given the widely acknowledged importance of next-generation networking. 

An exasperated Nilay Patel at The Verge asked in May why everyone from the tech industry to President Donald Trump keeps referring to the “race” for 5G when it is not a race at all because only China really bothered to compete. Patel shared none of Goldman’s concerns and thought it was silly to worry about whether China deploys 5G networking slightly faster than America or Europe, so he found the “race” rhetoric to be mostly empty hype deployed by telecom corporations and clickbaiting reporters.

“The race to 5G is a race that America must win. We can not allow any other country to out-compete the United States in this powerful industry of the future,” Trump declared in April. Unfortunately, that race began under his predecessor, whose distinct preference was for funding “green energy” projects. 


more recommended stories

  • Australia Joins U.S.-Led Shipping Protection Mission in Strait of Hormuz

    Australia will join the United States.

  • Spike Lee on Trump: ‘Why Are We Still Asking Is This Guy a White Supremacist?’ — ‘It’s Not Even the Question’

    Tuesday on CNN’s “Anderson Cooper 360,” director.

  • Fact Check: Elizabeth Warren Crowd Was 6,000 at Most, not 12,000

    CLAIM: The presidential campaign of Sen..

  • Ghislaine Maxwell’s In-N-Out Picture Is Photoshopped

    The first photo in three years.

  • No Employers Charged Yet for Hiring Illegal Aliens

    Nearly two weeks after the Immigration.

  • ‘How Many Times Is Biden Gonna Say Something Stupid?’

    Before Joe Biden’s persistent gaffes raised.

  • Charlie Kirk: The Left Wants to ‘Deconstruct Our Country from Within’

    Turning Point USA (TPUSA) founder Charlie.

  • 28 Shot, 5 Fatally, over Weekend in Democrat-Controlled Chicago

    Twenty-eight individuals were shot, five fatally,.

  • Lewandowski on Senate Bid: If I Run, ‘I’m Going to Win’

    Former Trump campaign manager Corey Lewandowski.

  • Why Buying Greenland Is One of Donald Trump’s Best Ideas

    Last week, the Wall Street Journal.

  • ‘We Are Everything He Loves,’ Except ‘We’re Powerful, Strong Women

    U.S. Women’s National Team star Megan.

  • Elizabeth Warren, Gabby Giffords Partner for Gun Control

    Democrat presidential hopeful Elizabeth Warren says.

  • Clinton Painting Not Only Bizarre Decor in Epstein’s NYC Apartment

    Following convicted pedophile Jeffrey Epstein’s suicide.

  • Cuomo’s ‘Fredo’ Meltdown Shows ‘The Godfather’ Is Our ‘Iliad’ and ‘Odyssey’

    Chris Cuomo may have only a.

  • Airport Security Worker Fired for Slipping ‘Ugly’ Note to Traveler

    An airport security worker in Rochester,.

  • Gunmen Kidnap Two Catholic Priests in Cameroon

    Church officials in Cameroon announced Friday.

  • Joe Biden Drew Only 30 Supporters in NH During Trump Rally

    Joe Biden drew only 30 supporters.

  • NYT Head Outlines Plans to Shift Trump Coverage from Russia to Race

    The New York Times plans to.

  • China’s Communists Call for Anti-Hong Kong Rally in Tiananmen Square

    The official newspaper of the Chinese.

  • Kamala Harris Tanks with Non-White Voters

    Democrat presidential contender Sen. Kamala Harris.

  • Trump on King Remarks: ‘Certainly, It Wasn’t a Very Good Statement’

    While speaking to reporters on Thursday,.

  • Islamic Lobby Feels ‘Ignored’ by 2020 Dems as Travel Ban Stays Popular

    The Muslim migration lobby is feeling.

  • Cardi B Asks Bernie Sanders About Tax Hikes, More

    Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) released the.

  • Israeli Deputy FM Says Ilhan Omar, Rashida Tlaib Will Be Denied Entry

    Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely said.

  • Six Officers Shot, Philadelphia Gunman Barricaded in House

    A gunman opened fire on Philadelphia.

  • Mystery, Anger Lingers Over Firing of Top State Department Official

    Kiron Skinner, a top State Department.

  • At Least 4 Philadelphia Officers Shot While Confronting Gunman

    At least four Philadelphia police officers.

  • Donald Trump Leads Top Democrats in North Carolina Poll

    President Trump is leading top Democrat.

  • Elizabeth Warren Calls for ‘Affordable, Gender-Affirming’ Health Care

    Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) called for.

  • Bernie Marcus: Making Money Is a Patriotic Act

    Bernie Marcus and John Catsimatidis write in.

  • Thankful ‘Animal’ Chris Cuomo Was Not Armed During Tirade

    President Donald Trump further addressed Tuesday.

  • Chris Cuomo’s ‘Fredo’ Meltdown Breaks the Internet with Memes Galore

    Internet users erupted with mockery in.