British Officials Worried About Angering Trump Over ISIS Captives

The United States has more expansive laws for incarcerating people who joined terrorism groups, including the offense of providing material support to a terrorist organization. It also operates the Guantánamo prison, where it holds several dozen terrorism suspects without charges and is trying to prosecute a handful through the troubled military commissions system.

Like many European allies, Britain strongly opposes the Guantánamo prison. Mrs. May’s government was afraid that the Trump administration might send the two British men there, a recurring theme in the ruling.

Last March, the ruling said, the British home secretary at the time, Amber Rudd, met with Mr. Sessions to discuss the case: “In the course of those discussions, he expressed the view that all foreign terrorist fighters should be prosecuted in their home countries. He referred to them as ‘prisoners of war,’ and to Guantánamo Bay as the appropriate place of detention for prisoners of war.”

After discussions with Justice Department officials in April, the British security minister, Ben Wallace, internally argued against pushing for assurances against the death penalty, saying that he had been warned that “there were strong voices arguing for Guantánamo” and that “the more restrictions the U.K. attached to support, the harder it would be to avoid that outcome.”

And on May 30, when the new British home secretary, Sajid Javid, met with Mr. Sessions, the attorney general said that “if the U.S. were to be willing to try Elsheikh in a civilian court as opposed to a military one, he could not see how the U.S. could do that without the U.K. evidence or without recourse to the death penalty.”

Ultimately, Mr. Javid told Mr. Sessions in June that the United States could have the evidence without death-penalty conditions, so long as it was not introduced in the military commissions system. That concession by the British appears to have persuaded senior Trump administration officials to focus on an eventual civilian trial in the Eastern District of Virginia on charges that would most likely include conspiracy in kidnapping resulting in death, an offense that carries the death penalty, according to officials familiar with internal deliberations.

Both Mr. Sessions, who was fired in November, and John R. Bolton, who became President Trump’s national security adviser in April, have agreed that a civilian trial is now seen as the most likely venue, according to former American officials. The family members of the victims had strongly pushed for that outcome. In a meeting with Mr. Bolton in late April, he was visibly emotional and pulled out a handkerchief in response to the families’ arguments, according to several people familiar with the meeting.

Source link

more recommended stories

  • Judge Delivers Major Setback to Trump Policy to Increase Coal Mining on Federal Land

    Want climate news in your inbox?.

  • Catching Up on the Mueller Report: What’s Next?

    A report of more than 400.

  • Should a White Man Be the Face of the Democratic Party in 2020?

    COUNCIL BLUFFS, Iowa — As Peter.

  • Mueller Witnesses Who Once Served in White House Now Fear Trump’s Ire

    WASHINGTON — President Trump and his.

  • A Reader’s Guide to the Journalism Behind the Mueller Report

    The Washington PostWhy did Obama dawdle.

  • Republicans Offer Health Care Bills to Protect Patients (and Themselves)

    The Affordable Care Act also requires.

  • On Politics: The Biggest Stories of the Week

    From the Mueller report to 2020.

  • Man Charged in Racist Threats Against Cory Booker and Rashida Tlaib

    Federal officials charged a Florida man.

  • Sanders’s ‘Slip of the Tongue’ Would Be a Problem in Some White Houses. Not Trump’s.

    “She is in a credibility bind.

  • ‘Medicare for All’ Is Hammering Health Care Stocks. For Now.

    The difference, or spread, between the.

  • House Democrats Subpoena Full Mueller Report, and the Underlying Evidence

    WASHINGTON — The chairman of the.

  • Mueller Findings Kick Off a Political Tug of War That’s Only Just Beginning

    WASHINGTON — Minutes after the Justice.

  • On Politics: Complete Coverage of the Mueller Report

    • Here are four dramatic passages.

  • Democrats Draw Closer to a Dicey Question: Whether to Impeach Trump

    WASHINGTON — House Democrats, facing some.

  • Right, Left and Center React to the Mueller Report

    Now that it is over, he.

  • Highlights: Barr Defends Trump Before Releasing Mueller Report – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search U.S..

  • Watch Live: Barr Speaks Before Mueller Report Is Made Public – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search U.S..

  • Democrats Are United on Climate Change, but Not on What to Do About It

    For Democrats vying to unseat President.

  • On Politics: Mueller Report to Be Released Today

    Good Thursday morning. Here are some.

  • Terry McAuliffe Will Not Run for President

    WASHINGTON — Former Gov. Terry McAuliffe.

  • E.P.A. Moves to ‘Close the Door’ on Asbestos. Consumer Groups Say Loopholes Remain.

    Want climate news in your inbox?.

  • On ‘Made in America,’ Trump’s F.T.C. Appointees May Be Out of Step With Him

    Two more companies, Sandpiper and PiperGear,.

  • In New Effort to Deter Migrants, Barr Withholds Bail to Asylum Seekers

    WASHINGTON — The Trump administration on.

  • Julián Castro Needs a Defining Moment. Has It Already Passed?

    Because Mr. Castro never ran for.

  • On Politics: Trump’s United Base of America

    While other presidents sought to broaden.

  • Court Rejects 2 Years of Judge’s Decisions in Cole Tribunal

    This article was produced in partnership.

  • How to Cover 2020: Assume Nothing and Beware of Twitter

    CHICAGO — Journalists have no idea.

  • For Democrats, Ilhan Omar Is a Complicated Figure to Defend

    WASHINGTON — When President Trump tweeted.

  • Gina Haspel Relies on Spy Skills to Connect With Trump. He Doesn’t Always Listen.

    WASHINGTON — Gina Haspel was trying.

  • Mick Mulvaney’s Master Class in Destroying the Government From Within

    The new agency had the feel.

  • On Politics: Trump’s Trade Style Could Cost U.S.

    • Oil purchases by China and.

  • The Rematch: Bernie Sanders vs. a Clinton Loyalist

    The blowup reflects ideological divisions among.