Mick Mulvaney’s Master Class in Destroying the Government From Within

The new agency had the feel of a start-up. Cordray, a Democrat, made an effort to recruit broadly, bringing in financial-industry veterans and former prosecutors, but Warren’s creation inevitably attracted Warren acolytes and veterans of consumer-advocacy groups, many of whom landed in the enforcement division. As the human and financial costs of the subprime-mortgage crash mounted, the new bureau was inundated with whistle-blower tips and consumer complaints. Cordray and his leadership team initially planned to focus on the biggest consumer-finance players, like mortgage lenders and credit-card companies; payday lenders were a relatively small industry compared with Wall Street. But it was growing quickly: The crisis had been good for business, pulling more middle-class families into the payday-loan market. And unlike banks, payday lenders were unregulated by the federal government. “It was affecting a lot of people at the margins who could least afford to run into trouble,” Cordray told me recently.

In 2012, the C.F.P.B. began conducting supervisory exams of payday lenders, a process that required them to open up their offices and books, and sometimes yielded evidence of predatory lending for the bureau’s enforcement team to take up. A company called Ace Cash Express, investigators found, harassed overdue borrowers by using phony legal threats. The investigation yielded a potent illustration of the debt trap: Ace Cash’s training manual, which instructed employees to pressure borrowers into paying off overdue loans by taking out new ones, illustrated its customer-service doctrine with a graphic resembling a recycling symbol, with one “short-term” loan fueling the next in an endless loop of debt.

Other investigations underscored the contempt that some lenders had for their new regulator. When the bureau informed Cash America, a major firm based in Texas, that it planned to conduct an examination, employees there shredded internal records and deleted recordings of phone calls with customers. Managers at the firm instructed employees to mislead the bureau’s examiners about its sales practices and stripped its call center of posters exhorting the employees to collect on debts. (The bureau later found that Cash America had illegally overcharged hundreds of service members and their families and ordered the company to pay a $5 million fine.)

The exams also provided an insider’s view of the historically insular industry, data that in turn guided the bureau’s enforcement lawyers and regulation writers. A bureau study of 15 million loans found that customers who kept rolling their loans over — taking out 10 or more a year — were the cream of the payday-loan industry, generating three-quarters of all loan fees. Advance America and other lenders disputed these findings, arguing that the bureau had undercounted one-time borrowers. But Cordray and his team saw evidence of a major regulatory failure: State-level reform efforts had largely failed to rein in the industry’s most abusive features, like debt traps. And lenders were devising ever-more-sophisticated tools to evade state regulation altogether: Some incorporated on Indian reservations or in offshore financial havens, selling loans online and claiming to be immune from state laws entirely.

A faction in the bureau advocated a strategy of hyperaggressive enforcement lawsuits to bring the industry to heel. Instead, Cordray settled on a two-pronged strategy, according to current and former bureau employees. Enforcement lawyers would begin prosecuting the industry’s worst scofflaws, especially the growing online lenders. But at the same time, the bureau would develop a package of tough rules that would apply to everyone.

In 2015, the agency outlined its core proposal, one that would eliminate debt traps: an ability-to-repay rule. Under such a rule, payday lenders would have to check whether borrowers could afford to pay back a loan before making it in the first place — a short-term loan would have to actually be short-term, not just bait for a debt trap. The rule would have real teeth: If companies lent money to people who couldn’t afford to pay it back, they could face prosecution and sizable fines. “We wanted to prompt reform in the industry,” Cordray says. “If they couldn’t reform their products, some of them would get out of the industry altogether.”

[Why jobs aren’t the solution to poverty.]

The backlash against the proposal was severe. Dennis Shaul, who leads the Community Financial Services Association of America, an industry trade group founded by Advance America and other payday lenders, told me that his group would have supported some limits on repeat borrowing. But the ability-to-repay rule, his members felt, was designed to shrink their industry. “We felt their solution was arbitrary,” Shaul says. The association worked with Jones Day, a powerhouse Washington law firm, to mount an all-fronts legal challenge. Advance America accused consumer-advocacy groups like the Center for Responsible Lending, whose alumni dotted the bureau and who had consulted closely with it on the proposed rules, of “infiltrating” the C.F.P.B. (The revolving door, of course, spun both ways: Shaul was recruited by the industry after working for Barney Frank, the Massachusetts Democrat who was an author of Dodd-Frank, and dozens of former bureau officials have gone on to work for the financial industry.) The industry mustered studies, including one by the bureau’s former assistant research director, finding that the bureau’s proposal would cut revenue so drastically as to put storefront companies out of business.


more recommended stories

  • Trump Will Not Release Tax Returns to Congress, Spokesman Says

    A White House official said that.

  • The Big Money Challenge Awaiting Joe Biden in the 2020 Race

    Former Vice President Joseph R. Biden.

  • Biden Looms, but Bernie Sanders Is Running His Own Race

    At several stops, he also offered.

  • On Politics: Pelosi Cautions on Impeachment

    • President Trump and his businesses.

  • Kamala Harris Proposes Executive Orders on Gun Control

    Senator Kamala Harris of California, the.

  • Democrats Seek Young Voters, and the Memes That Move Them

    Michael Bossetta, a fellow at the.

  • Two Early Presidents Who Questioned the Wisdom of ‘the People’


  • Supreme Court to Decide Whether Bias Law Covers Gay and Transgender Workers

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court announced.

  • Amy Klobuchar’s Big Idea: Bipartisan Appeal Can Beat Trump

    As her Democratic rivals promise generational.

  • On Politics: Will Democrats Nominate Another White Man?

    Good Monday morning. Here are some.

  • To Defend Against a Mercurial Boss, Trump Aides Wield the Pen as Shield

    Mr. McGahn said he kept notes.

  • Hospitals Stand to Lose Billions Under ‘Medicare for All’

    Whether hospitals would be able to.

  • Giuliani Says There Is ‘Nothing Wrong With Taking Information From Russians’

    PALM BEACH, Fla. — President Trump’s.

  • See Which Witnesses the Mueller Report Relied on Most

    A partially redacted report of the.

  • How 2020 Democrats Are Gaming Out Impeachment Quandary

    For some Democratic primary contenders, the.

  • Judge Delivers Major Setback to Trump Policy to Increase Coal Mining on Federal Land

    Want climate news in your inbox?.

  • Catching Up on the Mueller Report: What’s Next?

    A report of more than 400.

  • Should a White Man Be the Face of the Democratic Party in 2020?

    COUNCIL BLUFFS, Iowa — As Peter.

  • Mueller Witnesses Who Once Served in White House Now Fear Trump’s Ire

    WASHINGTON — President Trump and his.

  • A Reader’s Guide to the Journalism Behind the Mueller Report

    The Washington PostWhy did Obama dawdle.

  • Republicans Offer Health Care Bills to Protect Patients (and Themselves)

    The Affordable Care Act also requires.

  • On Politics: The Biggest Stories of the Week

    From the Mueller report to 2020.

  • Man Charged in Racist Threats Against Cory Booker and Rashida Tlaib

    Federal officials charged a Florida man.

  • Sanders’s ‘Slip of the Tongue’ Would Be a Problem in Some White Houses. Not Trump’s.

    “She is in a credibility bind.

  • ‘Medicare for All’ Is Hammering Health Care Stocks. For Now.

    The difference, or spread, between the.

  • House Democrats Subpoena Full Mueller Report, and the Underlying Evidence

    WASHINGTON — The chairman of the.

  • Mueller Findings Kick Off a Political Tug of War That’s Only Just Beginning

    WASHINGTON — Minutes after the Justice.

  • On Politics: Complete Coverage of the Mueller Report

    • Here are four dramatic passages.

  • Democrats Draw Closer to a Dicey Question: Whether to Impeach Trump

    WASHINGTON — House Democrats, facing some.

  • Right, Left and Center React to the Mueller Report

    Now that it is over, he.

  • Highlights: Barr Defends Trump Before Releasing Mueller Report – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search U.S..

  • Watch Live: Barr Speaks Before Mueller Report Is Made Public – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search U.S..