People Who Can’t Vote Still Count Politically in America. What if That Changes?

These differences would affect how redistricting lines are drawn, in ways political scientists have not yet thoroughly modeled. Daryl Deford, a postdoctoral associate at M.I.T., has generated 50,000 possible redistricting plans for the Texas State Senate. The results using only the citizen voting-age population produced on average some districts that were 50 percent larger than others by total population. Similarly wide disparities appear in hypothetical redistricting for the Arizona and Georgia state senates.

A world where urban districts hold substantially more total population than rural or exurban ones would make some states look more the way they did before a series of landmark court cases in the 1960s that established the principle of “one person, one vote” in state legislatures.

Before the 1960s, many states went decades without redistricting, leaving rural communities overrepresented long after many of their residents had moved to cities. The Supreme Court ruled that states had to regularly reapportion legislative seats to maintain districts of equal size.

The difference wasn’t just semantic. The scholars Stephen Ansolabehere and James Snyder found that after urban areas gained equal representation, more state money flowed toward them, and a leftward shift in state policies followed.

But beyond the implications for redistricting, state budgets or particular policies, there is also a larger question about who should be represented. The framers of the Constitution made clear that everyone counted in apportioning Congress (if not in whole numbers).

But at the time, it was perhaps more obvious why that should be true. The voting population excluded women, children, nonwhites, slaves, immigrants, poor people who owned no land, and plenty of taxpayers. Political maps that counted only white men would have ignored the interests of many people.

The framers of the 14th Amendment reaffirmed this when they debated how to replace the clause that counted slaves as only three-fifths of a person. Some feared that Southern states would block newly freed black men from voting, while still benefiting from their presence in apportionment. They proposed the same idea on the table today, counting only the voting eligible population (a prospect then, as now, that would have required “a true census of the legal voters”).


more recommended stories

  • A New Red Scare Is Reshaping Washington

    “This is the defining event of.

  • Inmates Freed as Justice Dept. Tries to Clear Hurdles of New Law

    WASHINGTON — More than 3,000 inmates.

  • Appeals Court Judges Send Emoluments Suit Against Trump Back to a Lower Court

    WASHINGTON — A federal appeals court.

  • Intelligence Chief Names New Election Security Oversight Official

    ASPEN, Colo. — An experienced official.

  • N.S.A. Contractor Who Hoarded Secrets at Home Is Sentenced to Nine Years in Prison

    The case of Harold T. Martin.

  • Polishing the Nationalist Brand in the Trump Era

    WASHINGTON — Ever since Donald J..

  • We Went to the Moon. Why Can’t We Solve Climate Change?

    [Read all Times reporting on the.

  • On Politics: Biden-Harris Rematch to Headline Second Debates

    Good Friday morning. Here are some.

  • How Trump’s Twitter Attack Against Democrats Evolved Into ‘Send Her Back’ Chant

    On Sunday, in what was widely.

  • Mortimer Caplin, Tactful but Tough Tax Collector, Dies at 103

    As I.R.S. commissioner in the Kennedy.

  • American to Lead NATO Intelligence as Iraq-War-Era Concerns About U.S. Linger

    NATO diplomats carefully balance the top.

  • House to Vote on Raising Federal Minimum Wage to $15

    “What we’re doing is working,” said.

  • 2020 Won’t Repeat the Mistakes of 2016, Whatever They Were

    WASHINGTON — Democrats still don’t agree.

  • On Politics: House Kills Impeachment Resolution

    • The National Republican Congressional Committee.

  • At North Carolina Rally, Trump Bets on Divisive Attacks as Way to Bolster Re-election Bid

    “Big Rally tonight in Greenville, North.

  • House Passes Intelligence Bill That Would Expand Secrecy Around Operatives

    WASHINGTON — The House passed a.

  • Trump and Epstein Partied and Commented on Women in 1992 Video

    WASHINGTON — President Trump has been.

  • 5 Ways John Paul Stevens Made a Mark on the Supreme Court

    WASHINGTON — Justice John Paul Stevens,.

  • With Name-Calling and Twitter Battles, House Republican Campaign Arm Copies Trump’s Playbook

    “I hope the lesson the N.R.C.C..

  • Top Myanmar Generals Are Barred From Entering U.S. Over Rohingya Killings

    BANGKOK — The United States has.

  • Iran Rejects Pompeo’s Suggestion It Is Willing to Negotiate Over Missile Program

    WASHINGTON — Secretary of State Mike.

  • Trump’s New Top Labor Official Is Expected to Advance an Anti-Labor Agenda

    Congressional Republicans, members of their staffs.

  • Roger Stone Is Barred From Social Media After Posts Attacking Russia Inquiry

    WASHINGTON — A federal judge on.

  • North Korea Warns U.S. to Quit Military Drills With South Korea

    SEOUL, South Korea — North Korea.

  • The Painful Roots of Trump’s ‘Go Back’ Comment

    It was there in 1882, when.

  • Democratic Fund-Raising: In a Packed Field, Five Candidates Stand Out

    Contributions From Individual Donors The bigger.

  • Pence’s Border Trip Illustrates Conflicting Messages About Detained Migrants

    Although many people were appalled by.

  • Trump Sends Negotiators to Geneva for Nuclear Talks With Russians and Also Seeks to Limit Chinese Warheads

    WASHINGTON — President Trump is sending.

  • E.P.A. Broke Rules in Shake-Up of Science Panels, Federal Watchdog Says

    Want climate news in your inbox?.

  • Joe Biden’s Health Care Plan Focuses on Shoring Up the Affordable Care Act

    After remaining vague for months about.

  • Huge Turnout Is Expected in 2020. So Which Party Would Benefit?

    The opportunity for Democrats, however small,.

  • On Politics: Trump Tells Congresswomen to ‘Go Back’ to Their Countries

    Good Monday morning. Here are some.