Report Says U.S. Airstrikes Have Killed 14 Civilians in Somalia

WASHINGTON — For years, the Pentagon has maintained that no civilians have been killed in American airstrikes and raids in Somalia. Amnesty International, in a new report released on Tuesday, put the death toll at 14 since 2017 alone.

The report linked the killings to President Trump’s decision to relax rules for preventing civilian casualties during American counterterrorism strikes in Somalia. Amnesty said it examined five airstrikes that killed 14 civilians and injured eight.

“In the incidents presented in this report, civilians were killed and injured in attacks that may have violated international humanitarian law and could, in some cases, constitute war crimes,” the report said.

It called into question repeated claims by United States Africa Command that there have been no civilian casualties from American strikes against the extremist Islamist group known as the Shabab. The report also attributed the discrepancy to failures by the American military and the Somali government to adequately investigate claims that civilians were killed in airstrikes and raids by United States forces.

Africa Command disputed the report’s findings and maintained it had killed zero civilians in Somalia. “Our assessments found that no Africom airstrike resulted in any civilian casualty or injury,” the command said in a statement.

Instead, American military officials said, extremist groups in Somalia are making up casualties and coercing locals to make false claims of civilians killed. “Al Shabab and ISIS-Somalia have a history of placing their forces and facilities in and around civilian locations to conceal and shield their activities,” the statement said.

But during a conference call on Tuesday with reporters, Defense Department officials acknowledged that it was difficult to verify civilian casualties because most American airstrikes and raids take place in areas that are controlled by the Shabab.

Before Mr. Trump took office, the military was generally required to follow standards that President Barack Obama imposed in 2013 for counterterrorism strikes beyond Afghanistan, Iraq and other conventional war zones.

Those rules, known as the Presidential Policy Guidance, required high-level interagency vetting of proposed strikes. They also said that the target must pose a threat to Americans and that there must be near certainty that no bystanders would die.

In March 2017, Mr. Trump signed a directive declaring parts of Somalia an “area of active hostilities,” where war zone targeting rules would apply.

Under the new guidelines, Africa Command could treat Somalia under less restrictive battlefield rules. Without interagency vetting, commanders could strike suspected Shabab fighters even without reason to believe they posed a threat to Americans.

In addition, the guidelines opened the door to permitting some civilian deaths if deemed necessary and proportionate to the threat.

“The civilian death toll we’ve uncovered in just a handful of strikes suggests the shroud of secrecy surrounding the U.S. role in Somalia’s war is actually a smokescreen for impunity,” Brian Castner, Amnesty International’s senior crisis adviser, said in a statement.

He called Africa Command’s assertions of zero casualties “all the more fanciful when you consider the U.S.A. has tripled its airstrikes across the country since 2016, outstripping their strikes in Libya and Yemen combined.”

But Amnesty acknowledged that its investigators were also hampered by security concerns. As with Africa Command, that prevented Amnesty from conducting on site interviews and limited aid workers’ ability to freely gather evidence. The group said it interviewed a total of 142 witnesses and survivors, with 65 who had witnessed strikes where civilian casualties were confirmed.

In one case, the report cited a drone strike on Oct. 16, 2017, against a Shabab vehicle. The attack missed its target and killed two civilians and injured five, including two children.

Amnesty called on Africa Command to “acknowledge civilian casualties caused by U.S. attacks and offer compensation and explanation to survivors and families of civilians killed in U.S. strikes regardless of whether the casualties were caused by a lawful attack.”

In 2013, the Shabab carried out an attack at the Westgate mall in Nairobi, Kenya, killing more than 60 people and wounding more than 175. Since then, it has adopted more sophisticated forms of terrorism, including nearly bringing down a Somali airliner in 2016 with a bomb hidden in a laptop computer.

To counter the Shabab, the United States has used Special Operations forces, airstrikes, private contractors and assistance from African allies.


more recommended stories

  • Visa Delays at Backlogged Immigration Service Strand International Students

    WASHINGTON — The visa applications of.

  • ‘Catastrophic,’ ‘Cataclysmic’: Trump’s Tariff Threat Has Retailers Sounding Alarm

    Already battered by the e-commerce revolution,.

  • 2020 Democratic Favorites for New York Donors? Biden, Buttigieg, Harris

    Mr. Booker, a fixture on the.

  • Trump Renews Feud With London Mayor, Calling Him a ‘Disaster’

    WASHINGTON — President Trump on Saturday.

  • Democratic Candidates Promise to Close Wealth Gap Between Blacks and Whites

    CHARLESTON, S.C. — Four top Democratic.

  • In Face-Off With Iran, Escalation May Depend on Who Prevails Inside Washington and Tehran

    WASHINGTON — As Iran and the.

  • Immigrants Brought Riches to Urban Schools. Now They’re in the Shadows.

    BALTIMORE — Mary Donnelly, the principal.

  • As Passions Flare in Abortion Debate, Many Americans Say ‘It’s Complicated’

    Few states have a political history.

  • U.S. Escalates Online Attacks on Russia’s Power Grid

    After Mr. Trump’s inauguration, Russian hackers.

  • Justice Dept. Backs Mnuchin’s Refusal to Release Trump’s Tax Returns

    WASHINGTON — The Justice Department on.

  • A President With a Taste for Planes Has a Plan for Air Force One: Paint It Red, White and Blue

    WASHINGTON — As someone who fancies.

  • Roadside Blast in Niger That Hit Americans Shows Growing Threat, Officials Say

    WASHINGTON — The roadside bomb that.

  • New York City Allocates $250,000 for Abortions, Challenging Conservative States

    [What you need to know to.

  • Under Fire, Trump Says He Would ‘Absolutely’ Report Foreign Campaign Help

    WASHINGTON — President Trump appeared to.

  • The Weekly – Trailer – The Youngest Known Child Separated From His Family by the Trump Administration

    michael barbaro From The New York.

  • On Politics: Trump Would Accept Russia’s Help

    • Twenty Democratic presidential candidates will.

  • The Subject at the White House Was Criminal Justice.The Subtext Was the Election.

    Mr. Trump has defended himself against.

  • Sarah Huckabee Sanders Leaving White House at the End of the Month

    WASHINGTON — Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the.

  • On Politics: Congress and Trump Clash Over Census

    • Senator Bernie Sanders on Wednesday.

  • Hope Hicks Agrees to Interview With House Panel

    WASHINGTON — Hope Hicks, one of.

  • State Department Defends Saudi Arms Sales Before Hostile House Panel

    WASHINGTON — A senior State Department.

  • ‘You Should Be Ashamed’: How Jon Stewart Became an Advocate for 9/11 Victims

    “It’s Congress’s job to fund it.

  • What Is Democratic Socialism? Whose Version Are We Talking About?

    Ultimately, though, Sweden isn’t what democratic.

  • 23 Democrats Are Running for President. Do Any of Them Know What They’re Doing?

    In the middle of May, the.

  • On Politics: Biden vs. Trump

    In the most ferocious day of.

  • A Truce Falters, and a Plan to Raise Congress’s Pay Falls Apart

    WASHINGTON — Last week, a group.

  • Climate Change Poses Major Risks to Financial Markets, Regulator Warns

    A White House spokesman, Judd Deere,.

  • Trump Calls Biden a ‘Loser’ Before Iowa Trip – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search Donald.

  • Rachel Maddow, Chuck Todd and Lester Holt Among Moderators of First Democratic Debate

    The first debate of the Democratic.

  • How Much Will Age Matter in the 2020 Race?

    Hi. Welcome to On Politics, your.

  • On Politics: Trump Sees Future in Tariffs

    • After years of showing little.

  • Trump Says Mexico Tariffs Worked, Emboldening Trade Fight With China

    WASHINGTON — President Trump has concluded.