U.S. Metal Tariffs Could Jeopardize Trade Deal, Canadian Official Warns

WASHINGTON — Canada’s top economic diplomat personally lobbied President Trump’s advisers this week to remove American tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum imports and warned that the levies could jeopardize that country’s ratification of the rewritten North American Free Trade Agreement.

Bill Morneau, Canada’s finance minister, said in an interview with The New York Times that the United States appeared unwilling to budge on the tariffs despite continued pleas to remove them. Canada has argued that the tariffs of 25 percent on steel and 10 percent on aluminum are harmful to both countries’ economies and make little sense given the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement reached late last year.

“We continue to advocate for the complete removal of the tariffs,” Mr. Morneau said on Thursday afternoon on the sidelines of the annual spring meetings of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund.

The United States and Canada have had continuing negotiations about the removal of the tariffs. One option that the United States has proposed is rolling back the tariffs in exchange for Canada agreeing to quotas on its steel and aluminum exports to the United States.

But Mr. Morneau called replacing tariffs with quotas unacceptable.

“We continue to think that the most appropriate way to move forward is just to fully move away from this approach,” said Mr. Morneau, who met this week with Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and Robert Lighthizer, the United States trade representative.

Mr. Trump has pointed to the new trade deal as one of his signature economic accomplishments, but it faces an uncertain path to ratification in the United States. Democrats, who now control the House, are demanding changes to the agreement, and Representative Nancy Pelosi, the California Democrat who leads the House, must agree to bring it up for a vote.

Ms. Pelosi said last week that the House would not vote on the trade deal until Mexico passes new labor laws that are required under the agreement. The revised Mexican labor law, which is devised to give workers greater freedom to organize, passed that nation’s lower house on Thursday and could go to the Senate next week.

Mr. Morneau said that he had been watching the proceedings in Congress carefully and staying in touch with his Mexican counterparts, but said ratification in Canada was also not guaranteed given the tariffs.

“It’s a real issue that we have Canadians asking why we don’t have agreement on that based on getting to agreement on everything else,” Mr. Morneau said. “I made that point to Secretary Mnuchin, that from our perspective steel and aluminum tariffs in two close trading partners don’t make sense.”

He added, “And they certainly don’t make sense in the context of trying to improve our trading relationship by signing a new trade deal.”

Mr. Morneau said that Mr. Mnuchin and Mr. Lighthizer were aware of Canada’s concerns but noted that the steel industry lobby in the United States, which supports the tariffs, is powerful.

At a Senate hearing last month, Mr. Mnuchin suggested that a resolution to the tariffs could coincide with congressional approval of the new trade deal.

Republican lawmakers in the United States have been on Canada’s side when it comes to removing the steel and aluminum tariffs. Senator Charles E. Grassley of Iowa, the chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, has also personally asked Mr. Trump to remove them and publicly called for their repeal this week.

“I’d like to see a resolution with Canada and Mexico on steel and aluminum tariffs,” Mr. Grassley said on the Senate floor on Monday, where he referenced the trade act provision used to impose the tariffs on national security grounds. “I urge President Trump to lift the 232 tariffs so we can forge ahead with United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement and eliminate the uncertainty in the North American market.”

Mr. Trump, however, continues to cast doubt about the future of the agreement. In recent weeks he has threatened to seal the border with Mexico and impose tariffs on Mexican cars — which the new trade deal largely forbids — out of frustration with Mexico’s immigration policies.


more recommended stories

  • Trump Will Not Release Tax Returns to Congress, Spokesman Says

    A White House official said that.

  • The Big Money Challenge Awaiting Joe Biden in the 2020 Race

    Former Vice President Joseph R. Biden.

  • Biden Looms, but Bernie Sanders Is Running His Own Race

    At several stops, he also offered.

  • On Politics: Pelosi Cautions on Impeachment

    • President Trump and his businesses.

  • Kamala Harris Proposes Executive Orders on Gun Control

    Senator Kamala Harris of California, the.

  • Democrats Seek Young Voters, and the Memes That Move Them

    Michael Bossetta, a fellow at the.

  • Two Early Presidents Who Questioned the Wisdom of ‘the People’


  • Supreme Court to Decide Whether Bias Law Covers Gay and Transgender Workers

    WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court announced.

  • Amy Klobuchar’s Big Idea: Bipartisan Appeal Can Beat Trump

    As her Democratic rivals promise generational.

  • On Politics: Will Democrats Nominate Another White Man?

    Good Monday morning. Here are some.

  • To Defend Against a Mercurial Boss, Trump Aides Wield the Pen as Shield

    Mr. McGahn said he kept notes.

  • Hospitals Stand to Lose Billions Under ‘Medicare for All’

    Whether hospitals would be able to.

  • Giuliani Says There Is ‘Nothing Wrong With Taking Information From Russians’

    PALM BEACH, Fla. — President Trump’s.

  • See Which Witnesses the Mueller Report Relied on Most

    A partially redacted report of the.

  • How 2020 Democrats Are Gaming Out Impeachment Quandary

    For some Democratic primary contenders, the.

  • Judge Delivers Major Setback to Trump Policy to Increase Coal Mining on Federal Land

    Want climate news in your inbox?.

  • Catching Up on the Mueller Report: What’s Next?

    A report of more than 400.

  • Should a White Man Be the Face of the Democratic Party in 2020?

    COUNCIL BLUFFS, Iowa — As Peter.

  • Mueller Witnesses Who Once Served in White House Now Fear Trump’s Ire

    WASHINGTON — President Trump and his.

  • A Reader’s Guide to the Journalism Behind the Mueller Report

    The Washington PostWhy did Obama dawdle.

  • Republicans Offer Health Care Bills to Protect Patients (and Themselves)

    The Affordable Care Act also requires.

  • On Politics: The Biggest Stories of the Week

    From the Mueller report to 2020.

  • Man Charged in Racist Threats Against Cory Booker and Rashida Tlaib

    Federal officials charged a Florida man.

  • Sanders’s ‘Slip of the Tongue’ Would Be a Problem in Some White Houses. Not Trump’s.

    “She is in a credibility bind.

  • ‘Medicare for All’ Is Hammering Health Care Stocks. For Now.

    The difference, or spread, between the.

  • House Democrats Subpoena Full Mueller Report, and the Underlying Evidence

    WASHINGTON — The chairman of the.

  • Mueller Findings Kick Off a Political Tug of War That’s Only Just Beginning

    WASHINGTON — Minutes after the Justice.

  • On Politics: Complete Coverage of the Mueller Report

    • Here are four dramatic passages.

  • Democrats Draw Closer to a Dicey Question: Whether to Impeach Trump

    WASHINGTON — House Democrats, facing some.

  • Right, Left and Center React to the Mueller Report

    Now that it is over, he.

  • Highlights: Barr Defends Trump Before Releasing Mueller Report – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search U.S..

  • Watch Live: Barr Speaks Before Mueller Report Is Made Public – Video

    Channels & Shows Home Search U.S..