Apple infringed three Qualcomm patents, jury finds

(Reuters) – Mobile phone chip supplier Qualcomm Inc on Friday won a legal victory against iPhone maker Apple Inc, with a jury in federal court in San Diego finding that Apple owes Qualcomm about $31 million for infringing three of its patents.

FILE PHOTO: A surveillance camera is seen outside an Apple store in Beijing, China December 12, 2018. REUTERS/Jason Lee /File Photo

Qualcomm last year sued Apple alleging it had violated patents related to helping mobile phones get better battery life. During an eight-day trial, Qualcomm asked the jury to award it unpaid patent royalties of up to $1.41 per iPhone that violated the patents.

The $31 million penalty is small change for Apple, the second most valuable U.S. company after Microsoft Corp, with a market value of $866 billion and annual revenue totaling hundreds of billions of dollars. But the setting of a per-phone royalty rate for Qualcomm’s technology gives the chip supplier a fresh line of attack in its two-year old legal battle with Apple.

The biggest case, filed by Apple in early 2017, begins in April. Apple has sought to dismantle what it calls Qualcomm’s illegal business model of both licensing patents and selling chips to phone makers. Qualcomm has accused Apple of using its technology without paying.

“The technologies invented by Qualcomm and others are what made it possible for Apple to enter the market and become so successful so quickly,” Don Rosenberg, Qualcomm’s general counsel, said in a statement. “We are gratified that courts all over the world are rejecting Apple’s strategy of refusing to pay for the use of our IP.”

In a statement, Apple said it was disappointed with the outcome.

“Qualcomm’s ongoing campaign of patent infringement claims is nothing more than an attempt to distract from the larger issues they face with investigations into their business practices in U.S. federal court, and around the world,” Apple said. It declined to comment on whether it would appeal.

In other cases against Apple, Qualcomm has won sales bans on iPhones in Germany and China, though the Chinese ban has not been enforced and Apple has taken moves it believes allow it to resume sales in Germany.

Qualcomm also suffered a setback with U.S. trade regulators who found that some iPhones infringed one of the San Diego-based company’s patents but declined to bar their importation into the United States, citing the damage such a move would inflict on rival Intel Corp.

The verdict on Friday could come into play in the trial in April because it puts a per-phone dollar figure on some of Qualcomm’s intellectual property. Qualcomm’s patent licensing model relies on charging phone makers a cut of the selling price of the phone, a practice Apple has alleged is unfair and illegal.

During an earlier trial between Qualcomm and the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, Apple executives outlined their company’s extensive negotiations to reduce those license fees to $7.50 per phone for Qualcomm’s patents.

The San Diego jury valued just three of Qualcomm’s patents in the company’s portfolio at $1.41, a figure that the chip supplier believes bolsters its contention that its licensing practices are fair.

“The three patents found to be infringed in this case represent just a small fraction of Qualcomm’s valuable portfolio of tens of thousands of patents,” Rosenberg said in a statement.

Gaston Kroub, a patent lawyer in New York not involved in the case, said the verdict was clearly a win for Qualcomm. But it does not say much about the value of Qualcomm’s entire patent portfolio and was unlikely to spark settlements discussions, he said.

“Apple is very skilled at handling appeals and taking a longer-term view. This isn’t something that will bring Apple to the table with any sense of urgency,” Kroub said.

Reporting by Stephen Nellis in San Francisco and Jan Wolfe in Washington; Editing by Richard Chang

Source link

more recommended stories

  • Huawei shipments could fall by up to a quarter this year: analysts

    HONG KONG/SHANGHAI (Reuters) – China’s Huawei,.

  • First American says product defect could have caused customer data exposure

    (Reuters) – U.S. real estate title.

  • Mexico tax plan for riding hailing firms may soon be mandatory: Cabify

    MEXICO CITY (Reuters) – A tax.

  • Amazon facial recognition ban won just 2% of shareholder vote

    (Reuters) – Amazon.com Inc shareholders overwhelmingly.

  • Uber’s first employee, Ryan Graves, resigns from board

    FILE PHOTO: Uber Technologies Inc. CEO.

  • South Korea orders further arrests at Samsung Electronics over accounting scandal

    FILE PHOTO: The logo of Samsung.

  • OECD members, including U.S., back guiding principles to make AI safer

    PARIS (Reuters) – The evolution of.

  • NASA chooses technology firm Maxar for lunar platform project

    FILE PHOTO: Tourists take pictures of.

  • China calls out U.S. ‘wrong actions’ as Huawei ban rattles supply chains

    BEIJING (Reuters) – China said the.

  • U.S. lawmakers want to help rural telecoms replace Huawei, ZTE equipment

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – A bipartisan group.

  • Allianz leads C$100 million funding round for fintech Wealthsimple

    LONDON (Reuters) – German insurer and.

  • U.S. could blacklist Chinese surveillance tech firm Hikvision: NYT

    (Reuters) – The U.S. administration is.

  • U.S. eases curbs on Huawei; founder says clampdown underestimates Chinese firm

    SHANGHAI/NEW YORK (Reuters) – The United.

  • Self-driving trucks begin mail delivery test for U.S. Postal Service

    (Reuters) – The U.S. Postal Service.

  • Retailer Amazon nears victory in rainforest battle over domain name

    FILE PHOTO: Staff chat at the.

  • Infineon suspends shipments to Huawei: Nikkei

    FILE PHOTO: A close-up of the.

  • U.S. intellectual property complaints a ‘political tool’: China state media

    SHANGHAI (Reuters) – Chinese state media.

  • Exclusive: Google suspends some business with Huawei after Trump blacklist – source

    FILE PHOTO: Visitors walk past Huawei’s.

  • Huawei founder says growth 'may slow, but only slightly' after U.S. restrictions

    Huawei Technologies’ founder and chief executive.

  • Exclusive: U.S. may scale back Huawei trade restrictions to help existing customers

    (Reuters) – The U.S. Commerce Department.

  • German finance minister expects OECD deal on digital tax in 2020

    Finance Minister Olaf Scholz addresses a.

  • Lyft is sued by investors over IPO

    FILE PHOTO: The Lyft logo is.

  • GMC trucks to deploy adaptive cruise control system

    The GMC logo is seen on.

  • Baidu swings to net loss for first time since listing, shares fall

    (Reuters) – Chinese search engine operator.

  • Huawei ban clouds U.S.-China trade talks, tech sector

    WASHINGTON/BEIJING (Reuters) – A U.S. bid.

  • Tesla to update battery software following car fires

    (Reuters) – Tesla Inc will update.

  • SpaceX to launch first satellites for Musk’s Starlink internet service

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (Reuters) – Elon.

  • FCC ready to let phone companies use tools to block robocalls

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. Federal Communications.

  • Facebook restricts Live feature, citing New Zealand shooting

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – Facebook Inc.

  • FCC to take ‘fresh look’ at opening key 5.9 GHz spectrum band

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Federal.

  • Huawei is not controlled by China, executive says

    FILE PHOTO: The Huawei logo is.

  • Ex-Autonomy CFO sentenced in U.S. to 5 years prison over Hewlett-Packard fraud

    (Reuters) – The former chief financial.