Apple likens Qualcomm chips to fried chicken as trial begins

FILE PHOTO: A surveillance camera is seen outside an Apple store in Beijing, China December 12, 2018. REUTERS/Jason Lee/File Photo

SAN DIEGO, Calif. (Reuters) – A trial opened Tuesday in a complex contract and anti-trust dispute between Apple Inc and Qualcomm Inc with the iPhone maker using a fried chicken analogy to explain its claim that the chip company is abusing its market power.

Tens of billions of dollars and the fate of Qualcomm’s business model are at stake in the case. Apple alleges that Qualcomm engaged in illegal patent licensing practices to maintain a monopoly on the market for premium modem chips that connect smart phones to wireless data networks.

Qualcomm in turn says Apple uses innovations that Qualcomm spent billions to develop without proper compensation and that Apple has interfered in Qualcomm’s longstanding business relationships.

A jury of three women and six men will hear the case over five weeks in the San Diego federal courtroom of Judge Gonzalo Curiel. On Tuesday, attorneys sought to cut through the technological complexity and frame key elements of the case in terms the jury could understand.

Apple has objected to a practice that it calls “no license, no chips” under which Qualcomm will not sell chips to a company that has not signed a patent license agreement.

Apple attorney Ruffin Cordell likened Qualcomm’s policy to a Kentucky Fried Chicken restaurant that refuses to sell a bucket of chicken to customers.

“You first have to go over to this different counter, KFL – Kentucky Fried Licensing,” Cordell said. “You have to go pay that ‘eating license’ fee before they’ll sell you any chicken.”

Qualcomm had not yet given its arguments as of mid-morning, but the company has argued in court papers that its portfolio of 130,000 patents contains technologies used by virtually all mobile devices.

The company’s position is that mobile phone makers need a license to its patents regardless of whether they choose its chips and that it has followed longstanding industry practices by charging a license fee as a percentage of a device’s adjusted selling price.

Reporting by Stephen Nellis in San Diego; Editing by Cynthia Osterman

Source link

more recommended stories

  • China calls out U.S. ‘wrong actions’ as Huawei ban rattles supply chains

    BEIJING (Reuters) – China said the.

  • U.S. lawmakers want to help rural telecoms replace Huawei, ZTE equipment

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – A bipartisan group.

  • Allianz leads C$100 million funding round for fintech Wealthsimple

    LONDON (Reuters) – German insurer and.

  • U.S. could blacklist Chinese surveillance tech firm Hikvision: NYT

    (Reuters) – The U.S. administration is.

  • U.S. eases curbs on Huawei; founder says clampdown underestimates Chinese firm

    SHANGHAI/NEW YORK (Reuters) – The United.

  • Self-driving trucks begin mail delivery test for U.S. Postal Service

    (Reuters) – The U.S. Postal Service.

  • Retailer Amazon nears victory in rainforest battle over domain name

    FILE PHOTO: Staff chat at the.

  • Infineon suspends shipments to Huawei: Nikkei

    FILE PHOTO: A close-up of the.

  • U.S. intellectual property complaints a ‘political tool’: China state media

    SHANGHAI (Reuters) – Chinese state media.

  • Exclusive: Google suspends some business with Huawei after Trump blacklist – source

    FILE PHOTO: Visitors walk past Huawei’s.

  • Huawei founder says growth 'may slow, but only slightly' after U.S. restrictions

    Huawei Technologies’ founder and chief executive.

  • Exclusive: U.S. may scale back Huawei trade restrictions to help existing customers

    (Reuters) – The U.S. Commerce Department.

  • German finance minister expects OECD deal on digital tax in 2020

    Finance Minister Olaf Scholz addresses a.

  • Lyft is sued by investors over IPO

    FILE PHOTO: The Lyft logo is.

  • GMC trucks to deploy adaptive cruise control system

    The GMC logo is seen on.

  • Baidu swings to net loss for first time since listing, shares fall

    (Reuters) – Chinese search engine operator.

  • Huawei ban clouds U.S.-China trade talks, tech sector

    WASHINGTON/BEIJING (Reuters) – A U.S. bid.

  • Tesla to update battery software following car fires

    (Reuters) – Tesla Inc will update.

  • SpaceX to launch first satellites for Musk’s Starlink internet service

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (Reuters) – Elon.

  • FCC ready to let phone companies use tools to block robocalls

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. Federal Communications.

  • Facebook restricts Live feature, citing New Zealand shooting

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – Facebook Inc.

  • FCC to take ‘fresh look’ at opening key 5.9 GHz spectrum band

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. Federal.

  • Huawei is not controlled by China, executive says

    FILE PHOTO: The Huawei logo is.

  • Ex-Autonomy CFO sentenced in U.S. to 5 years prison over Hewlett-Packard fraud

    (Reuters) – The former chief financial.

  • Exclusive: Amazon rolls out machines that pack orders and replace jobs

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – Amazon.com Inc.

  • U.S. presidential contender Kamala Harris favors look at breaking up Facebook

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Democratic presidential candidate.

  • Now you can explore a cave without actually going into a cave

    CHYNOVSKA JESKYNE, Czech Republic (Reuters) –.

  • U.S. says Huawei lawyer’s prior work at Justice Department poses conflicts

    (Reuters) – Huawei Technologies Co Ltd.

  • U.S. investor awarded $75 million in cryptocurrency crime case

    NEW YORK (Reuters) – U.S. entrepreneur.

  • Facebook rejects co-founder call for breakup, senator urges U.S. antitrust probe

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Facebook Inc quickly.

  • AT&T’s Mexico unit loses class action lawsuit to consumer watchdog

    FILE PHOTO: The AT&T logo is.

  • Uber set to debut on NYSE, hopes to avoid Lyft’s fate

    (Reuters) – Ride services giant Uber.