Tesla’s Elon Musk to square off with SEC in court at contempt hearing

NEW YORK (Reuters) – Lawyers for Tesla Inc Chief Executive Elon Musk will argue on Thursday that he did not violate a fraud settlement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and should not be held in contempt, the latest twist in a high-profile battle between the billionaire and the government.

Musk’s fight with the SEC, to play out in a Manhattan federal court hearing, has raised investor worries that it could lead to restrictions on his activities or even his removal from Tesla, while distracting him at a pivotal point in the electric car maker’s expansion.

Tesla, which built its reputation on luxury cars, has faced several production challenges with its Model 3 sedan, which it is counting on to reach the mass market, recently offering a version starting at $35,000.

The SEC on Feb. 25 accused Musk of violating his October 2018 settlement by posting material information about Tesla on Twitter six days earlier, without first seeking approval from company lawyers.

Musk has countered that the information was not material, and did not need to be vetted. It is unclear whether Musk will appear at the hearing.

The battle concerns a tweet that Musk sent to his more than 24 million Twitter followers: “Tesla made 0 cars in 2011, but will make around 500k in 2019,” meaning 500,000 vehicles.

Four hours later, Musk corrected himself, saying annualized production would be “probably around” 500,000 by year end, with full-year deliveries totaling about 400,000.

The SEC called the earlier tweet “obviously different” from Tesla’s Jan. 30 outlook, when it targeted annualized Model 3 production exceeding 500,000 as soon as the fourth quarter, and projected 360,000 to 400,000 vehicle deliveries this year.

Musk’s lawyers countered that the earlier tweet merely restated a forecast he had given on Jan. 30, when he said Model 3 production could total 350,000 to 500,000 vehicles.

They have also said the SEC had conceded during settlement talks that Musk did not need pre-approval for all tweets about his Palo Alto, California-based company.

On Wednesday night, Tesla repeated its Jan. 30 vehicle delivery forecast, but said first-quarter deliveries had fallen 31 percent from the prior three months to about 63,000. Its share price fell more than 10 percent in early Thursday trading.

It is rare for the SEC to seek a contempt finding, though some legal experts said the regulator has a strong case over Musk’s earlier tweet.

“It seems pretty clear that this particular tweet was not run through the scrubbing system that Tesla was supposed to have in place,” said Stephen Diamond, who teaches securities law at Santa Clara University School of Law.

FILE PHOTO: Tesla and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk participates in a “fireside chat” at the National League of Cities (NLC) 2018 City Summit in Los Angeles, California, U.S. November 8, 2018. REUTERS/Kyle Grillot/File Photo

MUSK SAYS SEC ‘BROKEN’

A contempt finding by U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan could subject Musk to new sanctions such as a higher fine or removal from Tesla’s board or as chief executive, legal experts said.

James Cox, a Duke University law professor, said Nathan was unlikely to impose a severe penalty such as giving up control over Tesla.

“We have to understand that Tesla is at a very important point in its history, and I don’t think any judge would want to be viewed in hindsight as the cause of the demise of Tesla,” he said.

“She could give him a good tongue-lashing, and tell him this is it, and next time she’s not going to be so nice,” Cox added.

The settlement resolved an SEC lawsuit that accused Musk of violating securities laws by tweeting last Aug. 7 that he had “funding secured” to take Tesla private at $420 per share.

That tweet sent Tesla’s share price up as much as 13.3 percent. Musk’s privatization plan was at best in an early stage, however, and financing was not in place.

In settling, Musk agreed to step down as Tesla’s chairman, and the company said it would adopt procedures to oversee all of Musk’s communications, regardless of format, and pre-approve written communications that could be material to the company.

Tesla and Musk also agreed to each pay $20 million civil fines.

FILE PHOTO: A Tesla logo is painted on a wall inside of a Tesla dealership in New York, U.S., April 29, 2016. REUTERS/Lucas Jackson/File Photo

The legal battle, which began in September, has not stopped Musk from being an outspoken critic of the SEC.

He has since labeled the SEC the “Shortseller Enrichment Commission,” recalling his attacks against hedge funds and other investors who sell Tesla stock short, hoping it will fall.

In a December interview with CBS’s “60 Minutes,” Musk said he did not have respect for the SEC. He also said his tweets had not been reviewed in advance since the settlement.

And in the early morning of Feb. 26, after the SEC filed its contempt motion, Musk tweeted: “Something is broken with SEC oversight.”

Reporting by Brendan Pierson and Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Lisa Shumaker and Phil Berlowitz

Source link

more recommended stories

  • Russia fines Google for failing to filter search results

    FILE PHOTO: The Google logo is.

  • SoftBank’s Son says Japan lacks investment opportunities, is AI ‘developing country’

    FILE PHOTO: Japan’s SoftBank Group Corp.

  • Amazon under EU antitrust fire over use of merchant data

    BRUSSELS (Reuters) – Amazon became the.

  • Ericsson says on track for 2020 targets as second-quarter profit matches forecasts

    STOCKHOLM (Reuters) – Mobile network gear.

  • U.S. Justice Department asks appeals court to pause antitrust ruling against Qualcomm

    FILE PHOTO: A Qualcomm sign is.

  • Senate to grill Facebook over plans for Libra cryptocurrency

    WASHINGTON/NEW YORK (Reuters) – U.S. lawmakers.

  • Amazon rivals ride on Prime Day marketing as protests unfold

    NEW YORK (Reuters) – Amazon.com Inc’s.

  • Huawei to invest $3.1 billion in Italy but calls for fair policy on 5G: country CEO

    MILAN (Reuters) – China’s Huawei Technologies.

  • Amazon workers in Germany to strike over pay, Verdi union says

    FILE PHOTO: An Amazon sign is.

  • Israel holds 5G mobile network tender, aims for 2020 launch

    JERUSALEM (Reuters) – Israel launched a.

  • China’s Ping An to invest in education startup iTutorGroup

    BEIJING (Reuters) – Ping An Insurance.

  • U.S. regulators approve $5 billion Facebook settlement over privacy issues: source

    (Reuters) – The U.S. Federal Trade.

  • Japan sets up working group on impact of Facebook’s Libra ahead of G7

    TOKYO (Reuters) – Japanese authorities have.

  • Volkswagen zooms ahead in extension of alliance with Ford to electric, automated cars

    , NEW YORK (Reuters) – Ford.

  • Macquarie-backed MEIF 6 Fibre outbids USSL for telecoms firm KCOM

    (Reuters) – Macquarie-backed MEIF 6 Fibre.

  • Trump blasts Bitcoin, Facebook’s Libra, demands they face banking regulations

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. President Donald.

  • Twitter back up partially after worldwide outage

    FILE PHOTO – The Twitter logo.

  • French Senate approves tax as U.S. opens probe into digital levy

    PARIS (Reuters) – France’s Senate on.

  • U.S. to probe French plan to tax tech companies

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. President Donald.

  • Need quick medical advice in Britain? Ask Alexa

    (Reuters) – Britain’s state-run health service.

  • Appetizing prospects: Uber founder takes aim at South Korea’s shared kitchen market

    SEOUL (Reuters) – Chef Youm Jung-phil.

  • U.S. to provide licenses for sales to Huawei if national security protected

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The U.S. government.

  • Nine companies set prices for listings on China’s Nasdaq-style tech board

    SHANGHAI (Reuters) – Nine Chinese companies,.

  • Facebook not invited to White House social media summit: company

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Facebook Inc said.

  • The high-tech trade dispute rooted in Japan’s wartime history

    TOKYO/SEOUL (Reuters) – Japan has tightened.

  • Exclusive: U.S. clears SoftBank’s $2.25 billion investment in GM-backed Cruise

    (Reuters) – Cruise, a U.S. self-driving.

  • Amazon founder Bezos’ divorce final with $38 billion settlement: report

    FILE PHOTO: 2018 Vanity Fair Oscar.

  • Fugitive U.S. tech guru: Cryptocurrency is next Cuban revolution

    HAVANA (Reuters) – On the run.

  • Boxing with giants: Italy’s packing robots are not just cardboard cutouts

    (This June 28 story corrects Romaco’s.

  • TIM to extend 5G services to six more Italian cities by year-end

    FILE PHOTO: Telecom Italia new logo.

  • UK competition regulator puts brake on Amazon’s Deliveroo deal

    (Reuters) – Britain’s competition regulator has.

  • Sweden to investigate telecom operator Tele2’s June network outage

    STOCKHOLM (Reuters) – Sweden launched an.