Lawyers for South Africa’s Zuma tell court he is being treated unfairly

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) – Jacob Zuma’s lawyers argued on Monday that the former South African president had been treated unfairly by prosecutors in his attempt to have revived corruption charges set aside because he is unpopular in the country at large.

Former South African President Jacob Zuma sits in court during a break while facing charges that include fraud‚ corruption and racketeering in Pietermaritzburg, South Africa, May 20, 2019. Themba Hadebe/Pool via REUTERS

Zuma, who was in office from 2009-2018, has applied for a permanent stay of prosecution from 16 charges of fraud, racketeering and money laundering relating to a deal to buy 30 billion rand (1.6 billion pounds) of European military hardware for South Africa’s armed forces in the late 1990s.

The 77-year old, appearing in court on Monday for the fifth time since the charges were reinstated in March 2018, has previously denied any wrongdoing and has said he is the victim of a politically motivated witch-hunt.

On the first day of the hearing, Zuma’s lawyer, Advocate Muzi Sikhakhane, described the former president’s treatment by the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) as “mob justice” and said Zuma had been charged because the country does not like him.

“Suppose we know that he may well have done what we suspect he did. Does he get stripped of human dignity, is there a reason to deal with him in a particular way because he is Mr Zuma?” Sikhakhane said in his opening comments.

He accused prosecutors of being biased against Zuma, who was ousted by the ruling African National Congress (ANC) in February 2018 after nine years in power marked by graft allegations and economic stagnation that led to credit rating downgrades.

Sikhakhane also asked the court to consider transcripts of so-called “spy tapes”, which he said provided further evidence of political interference used to charge Zuma.

His other lawyer, Thabani Masuku, said the application was not an attack on the NPA, but a defence of Zuma’s rights.

“They themselves (NPA) in their own words, from their own mouths, (said they) were wrong in the way they’ve dealt with the Zuma prosecution,” Masuku told the court, citing the NPA’s affidavits.


The defence and the state agreed on Monday morning to postpone the case against Zuma and co-accused French arms company Thales, setting Oct. 15 as a holding date pending judgement on the application for a permanent stay of prosecution.

Zuma’s lawyers also argued that there have been unreasonable delays to Zuma’s case that could lead to him not receiving a fair trial.

In a statement on Sunday, Thales expressed a similar view, saying it believed “it cannot obtain a fair trial” because of the very long delay of the case, together with a range of factors beyond its control.

Thales reiterated that it has no knowledge of any transgressions having been committed by any of its employees in relation to the awarding of the contract in the 1999 Arms Deal.


Zuma later addressed hundreds of his supporters in the city of Pietermaritzburg, saying the case should not continue because it is old and those who were part of the prosecuting team, witnesses and judges have either retired, forgotten the events of 20 years ago, or died.

“Also, the rights of Zuma have been greatly undermined and we have evidence to prove that,” he told the crowd of people wearing ANC t-shirts and army jumpsuits.

Zuma led the crowd in his famous rendition of “Umshini wami”, made popular by the ANC’s armed wing during South Africa’s decades-long struggle against apartheid and which translates as “Bring my machine gun”.

The charges against Zuma were originally filed more than a decade ago but the NPA set them aside shortly before he successfully ran for president in 2009.

Slideshow (4 Images)

After his election, his opponents fought a lengthy legal battle to have the charges reinstated.

The case is a rare example of a judicial system seeking to hold an African leader to account for his actions.

Zuma, wearing a black suit and red tie, was subdued in court. His son Duduzane, who faces culpable homicide charges in a different case, and a few of his supporters including a former cabinet minister and ANC politicians travelled to Pietermaritzburg to support their former patron.

Reporting by Nqobile Dludla; Additional reporting by Rogan Ward in Pietermaritzburg; Editing by Catherine Evans and Frances Kerry


more recommended stories

  • Magnitude 7.4 earthquake strikes Kermadec Islands in South Pacific: warning center

    MELBOURNE (Reuters) – A 7.4 magnitude.

  • Iran summons UK envoy over ‘unfounded’ tanker accusations

    FILE PHOTO: An oil tanker is.

  • Jailed British-Iranian aid worker in Iran starts hunger strike – husband

    LONDON (Reuters) – A British-Iranian aid.

  • State sponsor behind May tanker attacks, says UAE minister

    FILE PHOTO: United Arab Emirates Foreign.

  • Russia’s Putin gives China’s Xi ice cream on his 66th birthday

    Russian President Vladimir Putin (R) toasts.

  • Hong Kong media say controversial extradition bill may be suspended

    HONG KONG (Reuters) – Hong Kong.

  • Indian migrant girl, 6, died in Arizona desert as mother sought water

    (Reuters) – A six-year-old girl from.

  • U.S. and Gulf allies face tough task protecting oil shipping lanes

    DUBAI (Reuters) – The United States.

  • Migrants rush to enter Mexico ahead of security crackdown demanded by Trump

    CIUDAD HIDALGO, Mexico (Reuters) – Central.

  • French, Italian shipbuilders forge naval alliance

    PARIS (Reuters) – France and Italy.

  • Oman following Yemen escalation with ‘great concern’ – Omani media

    FILE PHOTO: Saudi security officers are.

  • U.S. blames Iran for tanker attacks in Gulf of Oman, Iran rejects assertion

    DUBAI/WASHINGTON (Reuters) – The United States.

  • Democrats – Trump comments give green light to foreign election meddling

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Democratic lawmakers accused.

  • White House spokeswoman Sanders leaving job at end of month

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – White House spokeswoman.

  • Two tankers struck in suspected attacks in Gulf of Oman – sources

    DUBAI (Reuters) – Two tankers were.

  • Hong Kong shuts government offices, security tight after violent protests

    HONG KONG (Reuters) – Hong Kong.

  • Macri’s key rivals in Argentina presidential election strike alliance with centrist

    BUENOS AIRES (Reuters) – The main.

  • Italy’s Salvini threatens to use strict new law on German NGO boat

    ROME (Reuters) – Italian Interior Minister.

  • Austria moves towards September 29 election as parliament draws towards close

    FILE PHOTO: Austrian Vice Chancellor Heinz-Christian.

  • Missing British hiker found dead in New Zealand – police

    WELLINGTON (Reuters) – The body of.

  • Trump and Kim one year on: A ‘beautiful letter’, stalled diplomacy

    SEOUL (Reuters) – A year after.

  • Thousands of protesters paralyse Hong Kong’s financial hub over extradition bill

    HONG KONG (Reuters) – Chaotic scenes.

  • Protests abating, Macron sends PM to map out exit from reform ‘death valley’

    PARIS (Reuters) – President Emmanuel Macron.

  • Uganda confirms first Ebola case during current outbreak, a Congolese child – WHO

    GENEVA/KAMPALA (Reuters) – Uganda has confirmed.

  • Botswana’s High Court decriminalises homosexuality

    JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) – Botswana decriminalised homosexuality.

  • Kazakh activists call for more protests over presidential vote

    ALMATY (Reuters) – Anti-government activists called.

  • Italy’s coalition to work to avert EU disciplinary action over budget – PM’s office

    ROME (Reuters) – Italy’s coalition leaders.

  • Japan PM Abe to meet Iran’s Khamenei, Rouhani this week

    TOKYO (Reuters) – Prime Minister Shinzo.

  • Turkish F-35 pilots no longer flying at U.S. base – Pentagon

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Training by Turkish.

  • U.S. House Democrats to get some Mueller evidence, Trump calls witness ‘sleazebag’

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) – Congressional Democrats and.

  • Defying law, Indian farm group says it planted unapproved GM cotton seeds

    MUMBAI (Reuters) – An Indian farm.

  • Russian media, celebrities protest against investigative journalist’s drug bust

    MOSCOW (Reuters) – Three of Russia’s.